Or at least the women—check out this hard-hitting piece of investigative journalism by MBC.
One can only hope An Seon-yeong watches all this before it’s too late.
Or at least the women—check out this hard-hitting piece of investigative journalism by MBC.
One can only hope An Seon-yeong watches all this before it’s too late.
Tagged as: interracial relationships, interracial sex, racism, xenophobia
Previous post: A Nuclear Cover-up
Next post: US won’t accept N. Korean nuclear state declaration
{ 115 comments… read them below or add one }
Kerist, do we really need to read more about this kind of thing? I’m trying to stick my head in the sand here! But of course, I’ll come back to read the angry gyopo response, how things are soooo much worse in western countries. Can’t stop myself from looking at the train wreck.
Argh. Angry. White foreigners taking our women. Things are soooo much worse in western countries.
Proceed.
Hey. It’s the one thing MBC does well!
They could have just as easily used a hidden camera to video tape Korean couples displaying daring intimacy like walking down the street with their arms wrapped around each other.
These hit pieces produced by slimebags come and go. They would upset me in years past, but today I just carry on with my own businesses without concern what locals might think about me. I can’t be bothered; I have too much work to do and a child raise.
Boooorrriiiing! HIV and taking money? That’s all they got? They need to step up their game and add some cannibalism or animal molestation.
Step your game, MBC. Weak!
It’s so over the top that the only people it’s going to convince are those already convinced because that’s what they’d like to believe.
When are they going to make a documentary about foreigners who befriend and hang out with well-to-do Korean males so they can get taken to the rooms salon and other such places?
@6 agreed! i’m just finishing up an email to MBC to alert them of the dangers of english teachers using bath salts and eating the students faces off!
Well, most of the usual journalists @ MBC are not exactly showing up to work to warn the Korean women of the evils of foreign teacher dating.
As I understand it, MBC is currently quite desperate to distract its viewers from the glaring 4-month long strike.
Damn, Bibimbong beat me to it.
BTW, the bath salts story—combined with the story about the guy throwing his own intestines at cops in Hackensack—pretty much made it official that I will never return to the United States.
If MBC had simply generalized a bit more, namely that all men — not just foreign men — are wolves hunting down Little Red Riding Hood, the report would be unobjectionable.
Jeffery Hodges
* * *
Christ on a pogo stick, Robert! You sound as scaredy-cat as Bevers used to before he returned.
Your brother is doing OK, isn’t he?
Ah, the old AIDS chestnut. I’ve hardly heard that one since the 90s–when every foreigner, bar none, sported the disease.
i dont agree w that racist shit but it is oh so tasty to see the world’s worst racists get a taste of their own medicine. just look at how hysterical they get.
“Victims of foreigners” That has got to be the funniest thing I have ever heard in Korea.
I bet some of these news people have been running these same pieces for years just cause it is an easy news story for them to pull out of their asses on a day when they show up to work too hung over to actually function.
Anybody want to bet that the guy sitting at the coffee shop with all the purported knowledge of foreigners in Korea is the same one that follows foreigners around Shinchon spying on them and has that hate foreign teachers website. Isn’t he the one always going on and on about foreigners and AIDS just like the guy in this video?
And human affection is a “problem?” Me thinks only for those who ain’t getting any. Someone needs to buy everyone involved with this “news” piece a kitten.
Despite this amateur news reporting, which panders to the lowest of tastes, other countries treat foreigners worse, like Thailand. As of late, there are more than a few unsolved murders and scams that target “farang” in that country – enough for me to strike it off of my list of places to go.
The producers of this fine piece of journalism should just run a 24-hour text banner reading “Foreigners Get Out!”
It would save a lot of work hours, allowing them to devote more time to protecting their children from the scary monsters.
#14,
Who are the world’s worst racists?
Hey, at least thank the Koreans for not going around murdering foreigners they encounter, unlike some countries like US, Aussie land, or kiwi land.
yeah, Koreans generally only commit murders when they go overseas, thank dog!
“What makes Korean women open their
legsminds so easily to foreign men?” – MBCAs usual the ones that will take the brunt of this racist/misogynist bullshit are those Korean wives and girlfriends who’ve made the life-destroying choice of having a foreign partner. Bad girls!! Shame on you! You shall be punished!
Foreigners murder and rape in foreign countries.
Go figure.
true dat, true dat. But as the video pointed out, we are generally focusing on whites, and their ratios for murder and rape in Korea are absolutely dismal compared to the Korean ‘score’ home and abroad.
Go figure.
America blames problem on illegal immigrants, japs blame on immigrants and foreigners, koreans blame on foreigners, chinese blame on foreigners.
Same shit, different countries.
So what exactly are you people bitching and moaning about???
Hide yo wife hide yo kid
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EzNhaLUT520
Haps ran the video and story earlier today. According to a reader who contacted Haps, she called MBC directly and they replied that “It was outsourced.”
http://www.busanhaps.com/article/mbc-under-fire-racially-charged-video
In “Hack en sack”…
Koreans had many reasons to misunderstand foreigners. They have not had good experience with foreigners in modern history. Westerners were imprinted for a long time as someone looking for indigenous sex in Korea. I’d assume service men like gerry had played the role in creating the stereotype of foreigners and associated Korean women.
However, I agree now is the time for Koreans to let go of the stereotype about foreigners. I’d hope more Koreans read comments at TMH to understand Westerners better.
#16 Do you really think the murders you mentioned are unsolved because of racism and not due to a totally incompetent police force? There are loads of unsolved crimes in Thailand that have nothing to do with foreigners. i would bank on apathy and thick-headedness before I pulled out the race card. As for the scams, if you think you’re getting a bargain at $100 for a baseball sized diamond, you might be better off staying at home.
Enraging AND titillating. That’s how you do sensationalism I guess. Just like the stories about 19 year old girls going to Ayia Napa for sex’n'drugs, imagine that had a lot of older men hot and bothered as well.
Gonna keep trying to enjoy myself with other human beings and let the haters hate.
Again, though, people like pawi and ‘sekki are lapping this MBC stuff up. If there was no ‘tard demographic that this kind of scaremongering appeals to, they wouldn’t produce it.
Is Xenophobia on a roll in NE Asia — or is it just another spate of bad journalism in places that are leaders in this, like China and South Korea?
Someone started a Facebook group to “organize a protest” about 5pm today –already 650 members have joined in a few hours.
So… lets see what ye ol’ expats do with the power of social media.
The founder’s mission statement (first post) reads: “Once we hit an appropriate number of members, we’ll have options to petition or file a formal complaint about this.”
Someone apparently has email addresses and the flood doth ensue. The consensus in the comment sections seems to be that petitioning is useless, international shaming is the way to go.
“Hi Seoul” takes on new meaning.
https://www.facebook.com/groups/319588811454559/
@33 cheers on them for the effort. but anyone remember what happened when the ‘dismantle the AES’ Facebook group hit those high numbers in 2009?
The Facebook group already over 1500 members and is still growing rapidly. It will be interesting to see what the group does with all of its members and energy.
There’s no journalism happening in this piece… because no journalists were involved in the production.
http://www.economist.com/node/21549008
It’s better that than this:
http://www.stickmanbangkok.com/Reader2006/reader2690.htm
bumfromKorea, that’s an interesting link.
But let’s think this through more carefully.
Nine out of ten reporters at MBC walked out because they felt the TV station was being interfered by the government to stop reporting such juicy stories like the one on the US beef mad cow, and three out of six new shows were suspended and cancelled. So they turn to rumor mongering on the internet with pod cast sites like “Naneun Ggomsuda”.
Which all begs the question, what are the problems with those government banned TV shows, and what news story reports are MBC running, that the government finds so objectionable?
Another question to ponder, could it be possible, this “expose” on the foreigners is exactly the type of story the MBC would like to run with freely, but can’t, because the government who’s fed up with irresponsible rumor mongering journalism, keeps shutting them down?
Don’t get me wrong, I don’t support government meddling in the media, but the Korean media itself is no bastion of responsible democratic institution either. This is all ugly in either case.
MBC may indulge in racist propaganda but this:
is truly laughable…dammit i don’t think this is the first time i attempt to break down this simple concept for you (and by you i mean you Engrishe teacher dipshits), but i’ll try again:
Korea has a 1+ tril. economy, it has a 1+ tril. stock market, it has Fortune 500 companies. It is a country fully integrated with the world economy at both manufacturing and financial level, NOBODY GIVES A SHIT ABOUT PERCEIVED KOREAN XENOPHOBIA. It will not carve even the slightest dent in Korean reputation, cos actually nobody gives a shit about you (yes, you dumass foreigners).
This is the same world that happily trades every year gazillion shillion of $$ in resources, finished goods and services with true champions of democracy and human rights like Hu Jintao, Vlad Putin and the Saud family without a flinch. Your third rate college liberal delusions don’t even register.
Christ i really can picture, say the Gubnor of Alabama, discussing with his economic advisors the opening of some Kia plant, going on along these lines:” The fuckin’ dog eaters wanna bring a few thousand jobs to the State ? NO way i heard Little Jimmy Graduate from U. of New Hampshire once was spit on by some drunk ajeossi cos he was walking hand in hand with his Korean girlfriend, fuck ‘em”.
Keep dreamin’ really, i mean look at the most liberal country in the world, Spain: they have gay marriage, they used to have wacko radical feminists in their governbment, they adopted the most welcoming immigration policy in Europe etc. etc. and damn their economy is so fuckin’ sterling, i can see flocks of foreign investors trampling over each other to sprinkle the country with their dough, yep sure
Million hagwon fodder march ! Let’s welcome the rise of the Korean spring !! We shall overcome !!! Hilarity knows no boundaries…
Being a Brit he should feel right at home
@cm
The actual beef (:D) that the journalists are having with MBC are the BBK scandal, 4대강 critique, and lack of coverage over anti-KORUS FTA protests, not the beef protest. It’s the lack of coverage that I’m having problems with – media blackout, a government sponsored one no less, is just not kosher with me.
And attributing 꼼수다 (I tried listening to it once… very reminiscent of a friend back in jr. high who was really ‘into’ political comedy) to the entire MBC strike is a bit… They’re in the same camp, sure… but I don’t think equating them is the correct analysis here either.
Well, that wouldn’t make sense. The MBC that decided to broadcast the “White Guys are Taking Our Women” special *is* the MBC that’s under the government that is “fed up with irresponsible rumor mongering journalism”. The guys that you are speculating would run such ‘expose’ are currently on strike, singing awesome YB song.
But even if (and I’m not a huge fan of Korean journalism either) MBC journalists are all shit-yellow journalists who only publish rumors, it is absolutely not the government’s job to restrict and regulate the Press. If MBC fucks up in terms of journalism, it’s up to the viewers (and advertisers) to punish them. The gov’t ought not to have any hand in the Press, no matter what state it is in.
As much as i hate to agree with anything Creo said, he has a point
Regarding #38: God bless you, Yangachi. God bless you.
The Korean media are not easy to defend, and some of the MBC strikers appear more motivated by pecuniary motives, but the LMB gov’t has certainly gone over the line in a self-defeating way and this has not been lost by press freedom watchdogs. Somebody jog my memory here, though: did the unions complain when Pres Roh Moo-hyun put his (Hankyoreh) guys in charge of the state or quasi-state networks?
“lost by” should be “lost on”
Re #39,
It’s as Robert K. said. Yangachi, you’re also getting a shot of good tequila with that beer I’ll buy you – man, that was searingly funny and spot-on.
LOL guys it’s all for-fun-blunders actually one of my fave posters here happens to be a teacher, i won’t say who cos i don’t wanna stroke his already abundant ego
“Well, that wouldn’t make sense. The MBC that decided to broadcast the “White Guys are Taking Our Women” special *is* the MBC that’s under the government that is “fed up with irresponsible rumor mongering journalism”. ”
bumfromkorea, the government may not have cared about a story about some foreign guys hitting on Korean girls, but this type of thing shows exactly the level of “quality” of the media that the government has been upset about when the media uses rumors for whatever they are against. This thing doesn’t just happen to foreigners, it also happens to whatever the flavor of the day is, including the government. Once again, the government is going about this the wrong way though, I agree that censorship is bad.
YB @#39,
That was funny.
YB (#46), I don’t have a big ego!
Jeffery Hodges
* * *
you know how much i like you, don’t you, yangachi?
YangachiBastardo, if I could buy you a beer, I would too! Bravo.
Yangachchi,
Thanks for stroking my ego, and don’t worry, I won’t allow your flattery to go to my head. Though it is nice to know how much you respect me. Sadly, as per usual though you are wrong. Women’s rights, victim’s rights, sexual minorities rights, efforts to eliminate prostitution…hell even the eating of fifdo….all of these issues have evolved in Korea in part from pressure put on Koreans by non Koreans. Your notion that Koreans are a society of rebels who just do as they please and damn the rest of the world couldn’t be more incorrect. Not even North Korea has that kind of independence from the opinions of the rest of the world anymore.
In other words…the carrot or the stick strategy has been very effective in making South Korea into a first world country in the last 50 years, and the prosperity you speak of is the result of South Koreans love for the global carrot and all the goodies that come with accepting it.
Pay no attention to the man behind the curtain! Creo69′s enormous ego was not being stroked. YB was referring to me! Though I don’t have a big ego. YB is confused on that point . . .
Jeffery Hodges
* * *
Funny stuff! I know an English teacher who had his arm broken by a group of Koreans because he was walking late at night with a Korean girl. Hilarious! I know another guy who had a bottle broken over the back of his head. His hospital stay was SO funny!
Oh, and I’ve lost count of the number of Korean women I know who have been publicly called sluts because they dated foreign men. But none of them were beat up, so it’s not as funny, as I guess. Although I do know a couple who broke off their engagement after the father threatened to disown the daughter. That’s pretty funny, right?
Carry on.
Couples break off their engagement after her father threatened to disown his daughter? Does that still even happen anymore? That’s a convenient excuse to break off the relationship that she didn’t want anymore – by blaming someone else for the decision she made herself.
Damn…there goes my master plan of ditching my wife and kids to hook up with Lee Hyori.
#57
Hey… that was MY plan! Well, at least the ‘ditching my wife’ part…
# 39 YangachiBastardo,
“Spain: they have gay marriage, they used to have wacko radical feminists in their governbment, they adopted the most welcoming immigration policy in Europe etc. etc. and damn their economy is so fuckin’ sterling, i can see flocks of foreign investors trampling over each other to sprinkle the country with their dough, yep sure”
Spain eased past South Korea
Spain – 4
S. Korea – 1
http://www.caughtoffside.com/2012/05/31/video-spain-4-1-south-korea-international-friendly-highlights/
Spain’s 3rd goal was a beauty(S. Korea’s defending wall jumped up – ball goes under)! The 4th goal went through the goalkeeper’s legs.
#55
Those women ARE sluts.
@60 so are you saying the wives and girlfriends of non-korean commenters at the MH are sluts?
#60,
That’s a gaffe.
enomeski—I’m going to give you a chance to explain #60. It had better be good.
@cm
But the shitty expose in question was not created by the journalists that you’re criticizing. In fact, the expose is the product of MBC under gov’t control – more so, now that almost all the journalists are on strike.
To me, it looks like a stalemate between Lee administration and the MBC journalists in terms of journalistic quality/integrity – with or without gov’t control, Korean journalism has a long way to go. It’s just that with heavy gov’t hand, the Press is not a Press (as you’ve mentioned as well).
But Lee has done a fantastic job of convincing me that the MBC journalists on strike are the good guys.
@jk6411
Who do you think enomoseki is, Joe Biden?
so the lone star debacle and korea being tarred as the “foreign peril” state country “hostile to foreigners” has no effect FDI?
http://busanhaps.com/article/foreign-peril-costing-south-korea-many-660000-jobs
like pelting players with bananas, right? get over yourself balotelli! leave it to a milano to give us all a lesson in racial sensitivity. milan inter 2009, fighting!
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2009/dec/13/italy-racism-football-mario-balotelli
YB (#46), I’m not an English teacher. But thanks anyway.
@63
Please let him explain it to me in person.
speaking of creepy white guys, japanprobe has a hundred nine commwnts crom creepy white trying to defend jap honor w regards to memorial plaque in jersey.on pg 3
#39: Well. Bloody. Done.
Yangachis has always been the best poster here… and #39 just solidified that in stone. Fckn priceless.
@33
Thanks for the heads up on that facebook page. All those lovely photos of couples (Korean and non-Korean) were quite moving. It’s really the best form of protest I’ve ever seen.
#65 in your link it says: “you can put your money in, but you can’t take your money out.”
That’s not entirely true. Despite their troubles, Lonestar made a very tidy profit, and made double the money they invested in eight years.
#65 BumfromKorea, “expose is the product of MBC under gov’t control”?? Sorry, but the press was even worse during the Roh gov’t era, when the press freedom in SK was ranked higher. This has nothing to do with “gov’t control”, the quality of press has always been bad. Go to youtube.com, they have all the old clips of MBC news warning about the dangers of foreigners running amok, well before LMB came to power.
“Despite their troubles, Lonestar made a very tidy profit, and made double the money they invested in eight years.”
Eight years? Too funny…the funny part is they would have made MORE money in much less time had Koreans not been holding up the sale for six years while they try to dream up new ways to steal back the profits in the form of this tax or that tax.
Lone Star will never get any justice in Korea and they are doing the right thing by taking their argument to a venue outside of Korea. Although, the longer this continues the more it costs Korea in the form of lost investment. I guess that is a form of justice. The fact that the Korean govt is now going after Lone Star for that building deal will all but guarantee this debacle will continue for a few more years at a minimum.
@72 the article said lone star was able “to sell KEB this year to Korean-owned Hana Bank for 3.4 billion won – an almost 50 percent reduction of what Britain’s HSBC offered in 2007, which was blocked by the Korean government wilting in the face of public vitriol.” so that was a misprint?
Bibimbong,
The best part is that the Korean govt forced Lone Star to sell their stake in a specified time in a market that was post global economic collapse…basically ensuring the buyer would get a very sweet deal. Lone Star has gotten screwed in every possible direction by Koreans on this deal.
With all the virtual high fives being slapped around for Bastardo, you’re the poster who really nailed it.
Bastardo and the others argue that because we are unorganized and insignificant in number that ex-pats shouldn’t bother to start, but all forms of minority protest and movements start small.
And you are further correct that Koreans are incapable of feeling shame within and only will through the eyes of the international community.
I also forgot to mention the rights of foreign workers which have improved immensely because foreign workers had the courage to stand up for themselves and found support in some very kind Koreans who help to promote their cause.
If Robert is cleaning out the stables of racist tards, why not a 2-for-1 deal that takes pawi along with ‘sekki? Line for line, there is far more racism in pawi’s screeds and he’s been defiling this place for 8 years.
I here MBC is looking for scab “talent” and they would be a good fit.
Might I suggest if you want your “minority protest movement” to succeed, you may wish to keep such opinions to yourself.
^RK, please elaborate.
#74 bibimbong, I didn’t say that was a misprint. I said it wasn’t entirely true about the statement “you can put your money in, but you can’t take your money out.”
As far as I know, they did take the money out that they made, didn’t they?
Let’s say i come to you with my chest swelling with indignacy, pointing my finger and stating, unsolicited, that Americans (assuming you are one) are incapable of feeling shame…no i mean, you are asking such question for real ?
(Thanks for all the support guys, i love this place cos it’s full of people way smarter than me and i love learning from smarter people.
I’m really busy now but later i’ll elaborate on Creo and bibimbong comments)
And despite the claims here that FDI is turning away from S.Korea, the FDI has actually increased steadily from end of 2008. And with Korea signing FTA treaties, FDI has jumped over 17% this Q1. I can just imagine all the Japanese parts manufacturers fleeing high Yen, trying to take advantage of South Korea’s FTA access to Europe and America. We’ve all heard it all before that Korea is falling apart because nobody wants to do business with Koreans.
@ 82 was meant for anonymous Joe, blocked the wrong quote
On further note, I’m not advocating the shabby treatment that Lone Star got from the Korean government. I agree that’s not a good way to increase foreign investment in any country.
I personally think Koreans may be a bit protective of their financial system.
South Korea’s financial system is often buffeted by outside forces.
Korea’s stock market often takes steep dives, due to foreign investors selling off en masse.
Korea’s currency often fluctuates wildly in value, due to outside forces.
(which is quite alarming to Koreans)
Also, Korea was hard hit by the IMF crisis circa-2000.
(During that crisis, Korean citizens banded together and donated whatever gold they had, for example, to help save Korea’s financial system.)
For these reasons, Koreans may feel protective of their financial institutions.
But this does not apply to all industries.
For instance, Koreans are welcoming foreign car manufacturers with open arms. They are sick of being ripped off by domestic car makers such as Hyundai, so they’re welcoming more competition in Korea’s auto market.
Allow me to also virtually high-five Yangachi. Priceless.
As for enomski, someone needs to get laid.
#82 YangachiBastardo:
I never said or implied anything about swelled chests and finger pointing.
In my time here I have observed an astounding lack of compassion among Koreans not only for ex-pats but also for their fellow Koreans. I have seen Koreans who not only lack a sense of right and wrong but also have no fear of the law because the law is not enforced or lacks provisions for enforcement.
I have seen Koreans not only turn blind eyes to but also (when they couldn’t turn their eyes) run from situations rather than help their fellow Korean, not to mention an ex-pat. I have seen Koreans turn away when seeing not only “but for the grace of God” situations but also knowing that they’re next.
I have seen Koreans forced to act: in situations of public shame when they are exposed to the judgment of someone outside their circle who has something that they need or want. In this country, Koreans have no fear of law; Koreans have a need and want for international standing.
Yes, I am American, and I believe that if I take Bill Gates to court that I can win on the merits of my case. I further believe that if Bill Gates had acted egregiously enough, the court would issue a smack down to Bill Gates. Do you think Koreans believe that about their employers, Samsung, or anyone else who happens to be one rung higher in the Confucian hierarchy?
I also found Bastardo’s piece energetic and entertaining, a fine piece of rhetoric. I also found it to be wrong (or certainly that I disagreed with it).
It’s tabloid BS. Move along. Nothing to see.
A_Joe,
You have obviously never been sued (in the good ole U.S.A).
As a random example, you mean that if I had a contract with MSFT, performed to the terms of the contract, and MSFT did not pay, do you think that MSFT with all its billions would not lose? Or do you think that Americans would not sue their employers?
Please, expand on your statement.
I was referring to your comments in #88. I think your belief that the little guy has a serious chance in the U.S. courts against a big and well financed guy is largely a fallacy. Essentially, this is what happens most of the time. Big guy gets hot shot army of lawyers, experts and consultants with a big pile of cash and outspends/lasts you. Now, if you are going against another little guy or a medium sized guy, then it’s a different story. However, most of the time Bill Gates’ lawyers will crush Average Joe’s lawyers. There are exceptions, but they are few and far between, albeit well publicized when they happen on occasion.
cm, thanks for clarifying. i’m no expert in any of these financial issues. i only know what they tell me in the papers. but yb’s rant about the int’l market being indifferent to korea’s perceived xenophobia (if any) just contradicted everything i’d read. businessweek’s article calling korea “hostile to foreigners,” a korea thinktank saying “foreign peril” is costing korea 660,000 jobs, and reports that lone star missed out on nearly 50% of a 2007 offer from hsbc because the sale was “blocked by the Korean government wilting in the face of public vitriol.”
but again, i’m no expert on any of this. maybe korea xenophobia is an unrealized boon for foreign investors by encouraging them to keep their money under korean control and invested for the long term. the foreigners just don’t know what’s good for them, they should just trust in the korean public to make decisions on what, when and how much they can sell for.
“I’m really busy now but later i’ll elaborate on Creo and bibimbong comments)”
Great! When you have the time please also enlighten me as to where South Korea dreamed up the current basis of their entire government system…hmm…democracy, assembly, freedoms and rights…three branches of government…amazing how they accomplished all this without a care in the world as to what non Koreans think of them.
Maybe you would do better trying to come up with a list of two or three things in modern Korea that have not been shaped and molded as the result of some form of influence from foreigners.
At this point the Koreans would probably be better off with Islamic influence.
It’s a little known fact, Creo, that just prior to setting himself alight, Jeon Tae-il was overheard saying, “Well, if it were just up to me, I could put up with the murderous labor exploitation. BUT WHAT WOULD THE ENGLISH TEACHERS THINK?”
Robert,
I recognize your need to occasionally belittle English teachers in an effort to erase your past but maybe it is time to move beyond that, eh?
That said, whether it is English teachers, US military personnel, Vietnamese wives of Koreans in the country side (the living and dead ones), or the handful of business people that pass through Korea each group has played a role in shaping aspects of this country for better or worse.
I guess if you want to attribute democracy to the English teachers that is OK with me but most will view it as a bit over the top.
Just to be fair, I am also going to give writers such as yourself and Michael Breen…to be fair though I think Koreans have been far more interested in his take on Korea than yours…and pop stars the like of Lady Gaga some credit as well for the almost completed westernization of Korean culture.
I don’t. And wasn’t.
Completely disagree, the evolution you mention toward a democratic society, one with a more relaxed lifestyle, didn’t happen under any kind of outside influence. It was an ENDOGENOUS process, meaning it was KOREANS who demanded (sometimes violently) change and obtained it.
The process was also sped up by a local elite who was enlightened enough to implement substantial reforms rather than halting their furious catch-up with the West.
Role of the foreigners in all this ? Little to none, the West would be just as happy with a dictatorial Korea the same way it placidly ignores tons of business and political partners, who commit rampant abuses.
Want some examples ?
Well let’s start with an easy one, China:
How many investments they loose cos of their horrific way of dealing with workers and ethnic minorities ? Exactly none
How many people give up their shopping at Chinamart despite all the pieties about poor Tibetans gurgled by Sharon Stone, Bono the douche and others ?
Again none
Let’s move over to the Gulf where, thanks to the oil bonanza, we can find some of the hottest retail markets in the world. How many of the LV, Prada, Bulgari etc. of this world are put off by the vile way they treat women and migrant workers ?
Want me to bring up closer to the Western world cases ?
Japan inc. incurred in exactly what losses because the country refuses to give up on whale hunting or because up til very recently they were unbelievably lax about child pornography ? Again the loss of image suffered by Japan and the barrage of subsequent foreign pressuring kinda elude me.
For fuck sake Hungary, a member of the EU, has a pretty much openly fascist and anti-semitic Government, who was comepletely ignored for years by Bruxelles, until the local Caudillo threatened to renege on their external debt of course.
You wanna know why ? I’ll tell you why: it’s cos the Western consumer is for the most part, despite some silly penchant for lots of kumbaya moments, a pathetic, piece of shit drone who whould sell their soul, their mother, their culture, their dignity, their technology, in one word everything to shave 2 $$ off the price tag of the lastest pair of Nike or 3 $$ to refill the tank.
Let alone adding 2 cents on the quarterly EPS of that shitty stock they inadvertently bought for their 401k
With all the due respect, this is a crock of shit, what made Korea a first world country was the hard work, the dedication, the patriotism and the talent of her engineers, her entrepreneurs and her workers
Touché, guilty as fuck
the bully in me can’t help but loving the scrappy, don’t-give-a-fuck-about-your -dumb-rules outsider
First of all i was referring to street level xenophobia not to mistreatment of foreign investors, it’s my fault i expressed myself poorly.
Your point still deserves some attention though:
1) Korea is now (more or less) a creditor nation, a net exporter of capital and technology. They’re more likely to invest abroad than receiving FDI. the same can be said about Germany, who’s like the biggest source of FDI in the world (or maybe Japan is, i don’t remember) while their inward flow is fairly modest
2) Korea chose to nurture their own industries, sometimes with fierce protectionism, climbing up year after year the added vaue chain, eventually producing their own brands. They chose this approach, instead of relying on FDI infusions. Allow me to say it didn’t turn out too shabby as the country year after year consistently outperform pretty much every other OECD nation in terms of growth. I’d say the benefits of a closed, protected market largerly made up for the lack of foreign investors.
Now if you could prove that going out nighttime for drunk Engrishe teacher hunting or beating up poor Viet mail order brides damage Sonata sales, you may have a point. Unfortunately Korea, like Japan, like Singapore, like Qatar and others defies the Anglo/lib orthodoxia and all the gibbering about “open” “forward-thinking” “dynamic” societies. Wanna know why ? Just one word: t-e-c-h-n-o-l-o-g-y
3) If i were you, i’d take, for the sake of my own networth, the rubbish reported in business-oriented media outlets with a pound and a half of salt. This is the same people who claimed FB stock would pop to 75$ on the first day of trading or, back in the early 2000′s, that Germany was the sick man of Europe
Now you’re starting to make some sense
but seriously man, pleasetell me you read the Guardian tripe just for giggles and lulz and you don’t take it seriously
belated congrats for the incoming baby ! And cherish those beer night memories as for a while your and missus wild dreams will be about 8 consecutive hours of sleep
YB and Creo both have good points, and I tend to be in between, and I agree with both. In my opinion it’s Koreans who made the changes for the better but don’t discount the effect of the outside international opinions. YB brings up China and Middle East, but Korea isn’t China and Middle East where they don’t give a damn what other countries, especially their enemy the west, think of them. Korea on the other hand, is far more sensitive toward opinions from abroad. This could be both a weakness and also in this case, a strength. For that token, I do not think it’s a waste of time for foreigners to be more active in Korea to bring changes for the better.
“Well let’s start with an easy one, China:
How many investments they loose cos of their horrific way of dealing with workers and ethnic minorities ? Exactly none”
Thanks for the “easy” one so I can just stop and not have to read that entire ramble of yours. “Exactly none?” Sorry, plenty of American businesses have either shifted their business to other countries where workers are treated better or made the Chinese companies upgrade the working conditions at factories in order to keep their orders. Apple for one and many, many apparel manufacturers in America have put China to task.
Improved working conditions cut into China’s bottom line…in other words, you are again wrong to think that China…South Korea…etc…can just toss the middle finger up to the rest of the world and do what they want. Sorry.
Wrong again, lots of Western businesses are shifting toward even cheaper countries cos China is too expensive for low-end manufacturing or they’re keeping they’re factories at home out of fear of intellectual property theft and quality and delivery time issues
Again off target: Foxconn story has become big in Western media way after it was already in the news in China. Now setting aside political reasons (curiously Chinese authorities tend to be oh so concerned with worker rights when there’s a powerful, foreign company involved) workers conditions are rapidly improving in China cos basically pepole ARE RIOTING ALL OVER THE PLACE…again an ENDOGENOUS FACTOR at work.
We all know how China powers-that-be teeter back and forth between squashing everything that moves with an iron fist and giving away some concessions to the plebs, we all know perfectly well that their own preservation in power is their main, if not sole, purpose.
I suspect neither of us will change their mind
cm&jk: great posts both of you and yes i survived another Mickey Mouse earthquake here in the land of cardboard real estate
“YB and Creo both have good points, and I tend to be in between, and I agree with both. In my opinion it’s Koreans who made the changes for the better but don’t discount the effect of the outside international opinions. ”
Cm…Koreans are very hard working people who are responsible for their success. In my opinion they are also way to sensitive to what others (including other countries) think of them and are far to willing to make changes based on these opinions. I personally enjoyed Korea more when I first came here and it was a bit rougher around the edges and it was less westernized.
“workers conditions are rapidly improving in China cos basically pepole ARE RIOTING ALL OVER THE PLACE…again an ENDOGENOUS FACTOR at work.”
Umm…and where did they ever get the idea they suddenly were entitled to better working conditions…hmm…I wonder!
Well….a little organization called the Fair Labor Association according to this article.
http://vr-zone.com/articles/apple-and-foxconn-agree-worker-condition-improvements/15405.html
And where is their headquarters I wonder? Ah!
http://www.fairlabor.org/contact
Who would have guessed! America!
And no, the Fair Labor Association did not just appear overnight in China in regards to Apple. The FLA has been working to improve the working conditions of Chinese in the apparel industry and other industries for years.
Nice to see a lively back-and-forth. Also appreciate YB’s sympathetic opinions on Korea, ever playing a terrific balancer.
It’s an oft-repeated question, namely, who takes the credit for the success of a miraculous drama that is (South) Korea since the 1950s? In other words, who’s the main actor and who’s the supporting actor here?
Sure, the good performance of a main actor is essential to make a big hit, but there are cases where a supporting actor plays such a prop as to “co-shine” alongside a main actor. In this case, the credit should most likely be 51% for the main actor and 49% for the supporting actor. And you all know who they are. Thank you both.
http://www.alternativeright.com/main/blogs/exit-strategies/glitter-imperialism/
“It’s an oft-repeated question, namely, who takes the credit for the success of a miraculous drama that is (South) Korea since the 1950s? In other words, who’s the main actor and who’s the supporting actor here?”
If there’s money to be handed out to the one taking credit, I’ll happily take all the credit I can grab. I’ve been on this planet since the 1950s, and I’ve improved my living standard year after year, just as has Korea. These parallels cannot be purely by chance. Since I wasn’t striving to be like Korea, then Korea must have been striving to be like me. So: “Show me the money!” And hand it over . . .
Jeffery Hodges
* * *
ecw,
Thanks for the link about Lady Gaga. As an American it is nice to see my tax dollars are finally going towards the right causes. Liberty for all!
Nothing against you fuckin’ poofies, but fuck 1 mill. people event ??!! Fuck that would cause traffic disruptions for hours and shit, let alone all the organisaitonal costs and garbage littered around and shit
if you’d ever organise anything like that in my town i’d fuckin’ hate you forever.
in rome it’s ok, they’re animals, they’re used to live like animals, they will hardly notice the difference
” Nothing against you fuckin’ poofies”
Come on now, is that any way to talk about the Vatican on a Sunday. Shame on you. The Pope and Santa Clause will have your balls.
fuck the poop he.s just a senile creep with a weird accent sunday is for soccer anyway
or as they say in italian ‘the day of dumping beer on the heads of foreigners and throwing bananas at our black countrymen’. loses something in translation, no?
You must log in to post a comment.
{ 2 trackbacks }