In January 2009 the New York Times (along with Wangkon) reported that the rough economic times had taken a heavy toll upon the plastic surgery industry in Korea. How popular was plastic surgery prior to the financial crush?
From a luxury limited to the wealthy a decade ago, according to ARA, plastic surgery has become so common that an estimated 30 percent of Korean women aged 20 to 50, or some 2.4 million women, had surgical or nonsurgical cosmetic procedures last year, with many having more than one procedure.
Our own Mr. Marmot also blogged in October 2009 about the high number of women willing to go under the knife:
A straw poll suggests that nearly 90 percent of Korean women would have plastic surgery to feel better about themselves. The Chosun Ilbo asked 232 women in their 20s and 30s who visited the website of matchmaking specialist Duo during Sep. 8 to 17 whether they had ever thought about getting plastic surgery. Some 86.6 percent answered yes. When asked whether they would get plastic surgery if it could help them get over anxiety about their looks or if they had the money, almost all or 98.3 answered yes.
Only one in 50 respondents or 1.7 percent said they did not wish to undergo plastic surgery. None said personality rather than looks is what matters.
Even Jon Huer weighed in with his article in Korea Times (August 14, 2009).
But an indication of just how serious plastic surgery is in Korea, and its apparent recovery, was the recent uproar over the tax exemption of penis enlargements even though breasts augumentations were subject to taxation (Mr. Marmot’s posting). Supposedly, Korean men are more self-conscious of their member’s size than women are of their breasts. According to this report - Korean men are not the only ones concerned about their size. The report concluded that size doesn’t matter to women (notice, however, the authors were males). Perhaps men with inferiority complexes should be looking at other options – including Korean ginseng and penis exercises (August 4, 2010).
InFebruary 2009, Sonagi blogged about the large number of Korean movie stars going under the knife to improve their careers – some of them not so successful. Perhaps the worst was this one reported in the Telegraph November 2008 (horrible picture).
Not surprisingly, male movie stars and singers are also having work done. A member of the boygroup Big Bang confessed that he underwent surgery following a traffic accident but had also contemplated having his face changed to look more like one or two movie stars he admired.
FOREIGNERS’ CHOICE
Sonagi noted that Korean movie stars are not the only ones going under the knife – but was Sonagi aware that Korea was on the verge of adding a new title to its list of hubs? According to the Choson Ilbo, October 29, 2010:
Kristan Davis, who played Charlotte in “Sex and The City,” pop singer Sheena Easton whose hit songs include “For Your Eyes Only,” actors Peter Fonda and Suzanne Somers and Yan Bin of Ruoy Chai International Group were all in Korea on Sunday last week.
They came to visit an anti-aging center which opens to the public on Thursday.
Set up by CHA Health Systems, the Chaum Center combines oriental, western and alternative medicines to slow down the aging process. The celebrities were given a medical check-up, spa therapy, stem cell skincare and a nutritional consultation.
Given, the article doesn’t claim that they came for plastic surgery but apparently, judging from articles published in Choson Ilbo (March 2, 2010) and (April 13, 2010), there is an increasing number of foreigners coming for just that – the knife. The Choson Ilbo stated that some 50,000 foreigners – most of them Chinese – had come to Korea for plastic surgery in 2009. This is a huge increase over the 25,000 in 2008 (Channel News Asia, March 27, 2009) and 1,000 foreign patients in 2006 (Joongang Ilbo, July 14, 2008)
Plastic surgery in Korea is becoming such a lucrative market that it has apparently threatened some plastic surgeons in the United States. New York-based Dr. Kwak created this list of three common misconceptions to help Americans decide whether or not Korea is right for them.
But according to a report cited in echinacities.com (August 12, 2o1o), Korea is not the hub of plastic surgery – that honor belongs to United States!
WebMD, a well-known American health and nursing care information website, reported on August 9th that the International Society of Aesthetic Plastic Surgery had announced the results of a 2009 global survey about the application of plastic surgery in different countries. Results revealed that in 2009, the three countries with the most practice of plastic surgery were the US, Brazil and China. That year, 17.5% and 14.3% of the world’s plastic surgeries occurred in America and Brazil; those in China take up 12.7% of the world’s total.
The other countries that ranked in the 4th to 10th in the world for most practice of plastic surgeries are India, Mexico, Japan, South Korea, Germany, Turkey, and Spain, respectively. South Korea, a country that had normally ranked higher, and is well known for their obsession with aesthetic plastic surgeries, is in fact in the seventh place this time around, completely overtaken by China.






{ 22 comments… read them below or add one }
Interesting article, Robert. Thanks. The author of the echinacities piece, though, seems to miss the obvious point that what is crucial here is not overall numbers but number of operations, per capita. It’s hardly surpring that China at a pop. of 1.3 billion would surpass SK at 50 mil. The fact that they are even close is far more significant. That said, even accounting for population size, the list is interesting and does say quite a bit about prevailing attitudes towards importance of physical appearance, the perfectability of the human body, etc. I certainly never would have suspected that Turkey would outpace Russia, e.g.?
Neff,
When you mentioned that Jon Huer character, I threw up a little bit in my mouth…
Sad that otherwise nice-looking people are so unhappy with themselves that they left someone do that to them…
Yaaawn…anything new here? Same old Korea-the-freakshow story peppered with dubious quotes (“Apgujeong is the mecca of plastic surgery in Asia…”) and questionable stats “…30 percent of Korean women aged 20 to 50, or some 2.4 million women, had surgical or nonsurgical cosmetic procedures last year.” (A conservative guess says it’s more like 75%.)
And for those expecting a new angle on an old story, don’t hold y0ur breath just yet. Let’s see, global economy tanks, Korean economy gets hit as well with local stock markets down by a third as excessively vain and narcissistic Korean women — and some men too — collectively tighten their Gucci™/Louis Vuiton™/Ferragamo™ belts, causing appointments to evaporate at all the best clinics in Gangnam.
Pity these poor doctors and all their clinics being shuttered due to the downturn. Guess they’ll have to go back to doing insignificant and small procedures like this self-pitying plastic surgeon so readily admitted: ““Before, I focused on profitable procedures” like breast enlargement, he said. “Now, I take every little procedure, even just removing a single mole.” Really??!! Are you f***ing serious??!!
I agree with 8675309 (aka “Jenny).
Shit about Korea and plastic surgery is so fucking played out. I remember when I was back here from 2004-6, plastic surgery was the topic that would be brought up when there was absolutely nothing else to discuss. Even then there was nothing new to say and this post makes clear that there isn’t anything new to say this time around either. Seems like the Marmot has a minimum number of contributions that guest posters have to do so Robert Neff decided to haul this one out to satiate the man.
And no, the fact of global economic doldrums isn’t a new angle on the story either. Lot’s of industries (more important ones mind you) have seen business drop. No big surprise that plastic surgery is one of them.
Koreans feel that Koreans are naturally ugly.
that is the heart of the problem.
Quote it.
#7, Charles Tilly, to be fair, Robert Neff is only repeating what’s on the Korean news all the time. There seems to be almost a national fascination with counting how many have got it, and how many more people are thinking of getting it, and how many people who got it but won’t admit getting it.
cm writes:
the block quote doesn’t work anymore.
There seems to be a morbid fascination by Koreans, with plastic surgery stories in Korea. It’s got to be, by far, the number one ongoing news story for the last two decades. It makes the industry sound much bigger, when the industry is already big as it is.
@cm:
1) “[M]orbid fascination by Koreans” vis-a-vis plastic surgery. Check.
2) “[The] number one ongoing news story for the last two decades.” Check.
3) “[Making] the industry sound much bigger, when the industry is already big as it is.” Check.
I have no argument with any of the above. Just one question: How is any of this new or fresh?
I’ll let you have the last word.
#12 Mr. Tilly – “I have no argument with any of the above. Just one question: How is any of this new or fresh?”
It’s fresh because it was posted by Robert Neff on October 29, 2010.
#8 wjk – “that is the heart of the problem. Quote it.”
Exactly. It’s a shame!
#9 “There seems to be almost a national fascination with counting how many have got it, and how many more people are thinking of getting it, and how many people who got it but won’t admit getting it.”
Uh..not really..where’d you get that notion from? Sure Koreans, especially the females, have an interest in plastic surgery. Getting 쌍까풀 수술 seems only natural with all the gals doing it. However, I have never noticed an obsession like what you have mentioned.
I would say Korea is a very appearance-oriented society. Therefor, a lot of people feel the urge to get surgery done because they feel they will be judged only by their looks, which is quite a shame. But let’s not kid ourselves, this is relevant to all societies and cultures nowadays. Sure, Korea’s case might be a tad more severe, but I’m certain everyone else will soon catch up. It’s just a matter of time.
#7 – Thanks for the laugh…..a minimum number of contributions to maintain my status…..lol. The nice thing about the scroll button – it works.
#9 – You are right – just posting what I come across in the news and that catches my interest.
To be honest – what caught my interest in this whole thing is the foreigners (after all – most of my historical research revolves around foreigners). lf we are to believe the data, foreigners coming to Korea last year for plastic surgery doubled the previous year and is nearly 50x more than 2006. To me, that is news. It is interesting to note the medical tourism exchanges between China and Korea. Koreans go to China in great numbers for organ transplants (remember all those stickers that once used to blanket the walls of bathrooms offering to broker organs for money? They are, for the most part, gone now).
Go figure: At my high school it was a rite of passage for the Jewish girls to get a nose reduction as a graduation gift, while here the chicas dream of a bigger schnoz.
Those ISAPS statitsics are always thrown around, especially when trying to make the point that Korea is not a leading user of plastic surgery. Look, as Cher said, its nobodies biz but your own what you do with your own body, and she furthered that comments by stating that if she wanted to put a pair of boobs on her back, that is her choice to make. I agree with the spirit of that comment whole-heartedly, BUT, lets stop using inaccurate statistics to prove a point, shall we. The ISAPS stats are based on reporting from tehir membership. As per map below, there are only 18 members of the ISAPS in Korea. Me thinks there are more tahn 18 plastic surgeons in half a block in Gangnam.
http://www.isaps.org/society.php?subsection=worldmap
Oh, and about the Cher comment above, I think the issue with Korea becomes even more complex due to the age of the individuals in which much of these procedures are performed on, and the aspect of parental pressure, and “keeping up with the Kims” attitutude that leads to such a large amount of young girls going under the knife.
My apologies, in that the ISAPS has changed their ranking methods this year:
http://www.isaps.org/uploads/news_pdf/Raw_data_Survey2009.pdf
Please note, however, that they are based on “Board Certified” Plastic Surgeons, and they list Korea as only having 1,277. My understanding is that these procedures are often NOT perforemed by board certified surgeons (and this is not just about Korea). Also puts the data nto doubt. Doesnt jive with the 30% numbers from the NY Times either.
“Uh..not really..where’d you get that notion from?”
From reading all the online news and blogs. There’s at least one plastic surgery story in at least one news site, once a day.
I’m serious and I’m not exaggerating. It almost feels like it’s some kind of a bragging thing going on. “Hey world… we are rich and stuck up enough to do lots and lots of plastic surgeries! Now look at us!” I’m not saying that’s what it really is, but sometimes I can’t help but to get that feeling. If the media is milking this story to death, then there must be a very receptive audience that keep the readerships up.
Exactly. Looking at the number of surgeries per capita is more telling of the trend and a more useful indicator.
I can certainly understand someone from China going to Korea for a procedure. Given the choice would you pick a experienced Korean clinic or an inexperienced Chinese one? That being said, I recall several years ago some Korea cosmetic surgeons were setting up shop in China. I don’t know whether they were able to obtain licences – that’s often tricky. But the clinics could be used for consultations and then the work performed in Korea. For US- and other western-based ethnic Koreans Korea is a good fit; I reckon that’s why Dr Kwak is concerned.
And to collect an appearance fee. Also, I reckon one can’t get stem cell creams and ointments in the States if said stem cells are sourced from humans.
Are spa visits and massages included in the figures? Or was this tossed in by the reporter due to the fame of Davis, Easton, Fonda, Sommers and Yan (or is it Bin?)?
So your conservative guess is that 75% had plastic surgery in ONE year.
Hate to see your wild guess!!
Of topic, but Kim Jong-il’s son supposedly got cosmetic surgery too look more like his grand-father.
You must log in to post a comment.