Multiracial Koreans Live Very Difficult Lives: Report

by Robert Koehler on March 17, 2009


Sweet image of Hines Ward at LMB’s inauguration. Stolen from linked article.

OhMyNews looks at the “desolate realities of Korea’s Hines Wards” — the first and second generation of post-Korean War multiracial Koreans experience terrible difficulties, including an average monthly income of less than a million won with most laboring as irregular employees on a time and contract basis.

According to a report by Sungkyunkwan University social welfare professor Kim Tong-won, the average monthly income of first and second generation multiracial Koreans was just 865,400 won, and six out of 10 worked as irregular workers. Due to their low incomes, 55.64% said they could not get medical treatment of any kind.

The report will be was read today at a hearing at the office of Rep. Kim Chung-hwan (GNP).

Professor Kim’s report, conducted between October of last year to February of this year, polled 333 of Korea’s 546 (presumed) first and second generation multiracial Koreans about their lives and major desires.

For the purposes of Kim’s survey, the multiracial Koreans surveyed are those born to US military fathers and Korean mothers after the Korean War. The first generation are those born in the era immediately after the Korean War, while the second generation are those born between 1961 (when Korea passed an anti-prostitution law) and 1982, when the US amended its immigration law.

Those born of white fathers (51.64%) outnumbered those born to black fathers (41.39%), and most live in Gyeonggi-do (51.39%) and Seoul (21.67%). Some 85.77% have not graduated high school, including 25.38% who have no schooling at all. Only 14.23% have a community college education or more. By religion, 41.74% are Protestants, 39.57% are Buddhists, and 3.91% are Catholics.

Some 42.53% have been unable to get jobs due to their physical characteristics or low education. Those that did get jobs generally earned their living as restaurant kitchen cleaners and waiters/watresses (27.89%) and construction workes (15.65%). Some 6.80% worked as bar hostesses, two worked as bar performers, two worked as athletes/entertainers/housekeepers (?), while one was a clergyman.

Some 66 out of 100 worked as irregular workers. Some 34.01% worked in hourly part-time jobs while 31.97% did contract work, meaning 65.98% were irregular workers. Only 17.01% were regular employees, and 8.16% were self-employed.

When seeking jobs, these individuals experience great difficulties — 26.67% have been refused jobs due to low education, but 18.43% have been refused jobs due to being multiracial and 12.94% have been discriminated against for being multiracial. 18.43% say the jobs they can get are limited due to their race. Some 49.51% said they’ve been unable to get jobs due to poor health.

Professor Kim said when getting jobs, multiracial men suffer more discrimination than women due to their race, and the second and third generation of multiracial Koreans experience more discrimination than the first generation.

Low Personal and Family Incomes

Multiracial Koreans earn quite little, too. The average monthly income of the polled multiracial Koreans was just 865,400 won; their average monthly household income was just 3.07 million won. There was one individual who made no income, and one household that made just 200,000 won. Some 59.75% of those polled had debts, with the average debt being 13.1525 million won.

As for their standard of living, 43.13% said they were in the lower lower class. When combined with the 33.59% who put themselves in the upper lower class, a full 76.72%put themselves in the lower class. Only 6.11% put themselves in the upper-middle class or above. Some 65.46% said they live in rental places, while the average key money paid was 9.0461 million won.

Kim noted that 29.12% received welfare support, meaning almost 30% were currently experiencing exonomic difficulties.

Despite the fact that most were suffering from musculoskeletal disorders due to their difficult lives, 55.63% were not receiving any medical treatment whatsoever. As for why they were receiving treatment, 96.10% cited their difficult existences.

Other difficulties cites including being told off by society due to their parents (68.0%), discrimination in employment (54.4%), discrimination and ostracization at school (52.0%), and difficulties in dating and marriage (45.9%). Of these, discrimination and ostracization at school was selected first by the most respondents.

Some 68.40% said they’ve been sweared at, 47.98% said they’ve been discriminated against at public institutions and offices, 38.27% said they’ve been sexually harrassed or assaulted, and 15% said they’ve been assaulted. Some 59.60% said they’ve suffered severe depression and 10.29% said they’ve attempted suicide due to this discrimination and abuse.

In particular, multiracial Koreans with children worried about passing on their poverty (36.60%), social discrimination (18.95%) and education issues (15.03%).

As for support measures they needed most, 71.5% cited “guaranteed secure housing,” and 60.1% said a system to correct social discrimination. Some 31.6% said support for multiracial Korean association was needed, while 30.4% wanted cost-of-living support and 28.9% wanted health and medical support.

Multiracial Koreans vs. Multicultural Families

Professor Kim noted that nothing is being done for these multiracial Koreans — for social cohesion, we needed to solve the difficulties suffered by Korean War-related multiracial Koreans before dealing with the issues of “marriage immigrants” and migrant laborers.

He explained that “multicultural families” as designated by the Multicultural Families Support Law do not include Korean War-related multicultural Koreans, so no systemic support is being given to them. A realistic alternative would be to include them in the law.

Another alternative would be a law similar to a multiracial Korean support bill proposed by Rep. Kim Chung-hwan in 2006, although Prof. Kim believed this had less of a chance getting realized.

Rep. Kim Chung-hwan, however, gave his bill another shot last October. Kim has given war-related multiracial Koreans much attention from the time he was ward head in Gangdong-gu.

An offical at the lawmaker’s office said the bill fell as it was being considered alongside the Multicultural Family Support Law, but since the latter does not include (war-related) multiracial Koreans, they needed protection and support.

The official said the multiracial Koreans were a sadness of the age created as US troops were based in Korea. Born unintentionally, they were suffering discrimination due to their appearance and needed legal support, he stressed.

Rep. Kim and Prof. Kim held a hearing today in order to launch another bill to help multiracial Koreans.

As Hines Ward Goes

In a telephone interview with OhMyNews, Bae Gi-cheol of the Korean General Association of International Families (?) said he was pained to see that Korean society cared only for so-called multicultural families, such as Asian women who immigrate to Korea to marry. He said the only time people are really interested in when Hines Ward visits Korea, and when he leaves, interest disappears.

Bae said there’s nothing in the Constitution calling on people to discriminate on the basis of skin color. He stressed that multiracial Koreans, too, have the right to pursue happiness, but because they’ve been excessively excluded, a support law was needed.

{ 30 comments… read them below or add one }

1 Maranag March 17, 2009 at 3:01 pm

The fact that most are undereducated seems to suggest that public schools were a bad fit due to racial issues. Without schooling, (and in the case of men: not being able to serve in the army) it’s no wonder that these individuals have a hard time finding work.

It doesn’t say, but I guess the assumption is that these people were brought up by a single Korean parent, likely the mother (who, as the article seems to suggest, may have been a prostitute). Far be it for me to cast stereotypes on the kind of hookers that frequented US military bases back in the day, but perhaps they lacked the means or the drive to instill in their unwanted children a solid respect for education.

A survey that compares the lives of these multicultural children in Korea with children who were brought back to the US would be interesting.

Trying not to be glib, the situation these people face here in Korea is terrible and my heart goes out to them.

2 misuda March 17, 2009 at 11:03 pm

Were all of the guests at the inauguration segregated according to race as per the photo? Blacks with blacks, whites with whites, etc..
Did they use Ward as a kind of defensive buffer between the Koreans and the Blacks, or was he selected to play as a receiver for the Koreans.
Is the guy on Ward’s left so fluent in Korean that he does not need to use a translator, or does he just choose to not listen to the drivel that comes out of peoples mouths at such events.
Does anyone have a link to the report, or do I have to look for it myself. How many of these mixies were from broken/single parent homes?
Can we put the mixy girls in wheelchairs and send them to LA?

3 Jewook March 18, 2009 at 12:10 am

Speaking of mixy girls, here are some song by singer & rapper Yoon Mi-rae(윤미래, aka T). Her 2007 full album is interesting because track 9 “검은 행복” (Black Happiness ?) features her father who’s Black, in it she sings about her hardships as a multiracial. Link Though I like track 3 “잊었니…” (Did You Forget…) a lot more. Link I absolutely love her latest single “떠나지마…” (Don’t Leave… ?) Link Fantastic.

4 misuda March 18, 2009 at 1:20 am

Singer AND rapper? Jeckle AND Hyde?
Sounds like she is suffering from some variant of bipolar disease.
Or is the rapping a journey into her inner city ghetto roots?

5 David Dodge II March 18, 2009 at 1:57 am

This is a link here regarding a great documentary.

Directed by Oscar-nominated director Shuibo Wang.

I think you guys here should watch it.

http://video.google.com/videosearch?q=they+chose+china&emb=0&aq=f#

6 NetizenKim March 18, 2009 at 2:15 am

He said the only time people are really interested in when Hines Ward visits Korea, and when he leaves, interest disappears.

Anyone ever see Spike Lee’s 1989 Do the Right Thing?.

There’s a scene in there where Pino (played by John Turturro) and Mookie (played by Spike Lee) and having a discussion about race. Mookie asks Pino how is it possible that he admires Michael Jordan and Magic Johnson but still dislike black people.

7 David Dodge II March 18, 2009 at 2:24 am

Despite the people like Net Kim who love hate and misunderstanding between people who try to prevent others from objectively viewing some history on the predicament for the American, Korean and Chinese people, the truth will prevail.

This is a very interesting video directed by Oscar nominated Canadian-Chinese director Shuibo Wang, all people here should watch it.

http://video.google.com/videosearch?q=they+chose+china&emb=0&aq=f#

8 NetizenKim March 18, 2009 at 2:36 am

David, I already saw that video about a year ago. You like it because it is very sympathetic toward GIs. There is no such thing as completely objective history.

9 JW March 18, 2009 at 3:01 am

Wow, 49% have health problems severe enough to hamper their job search? Does anyone know more about what this number means exactly?

10 JW March 18, 2009 at 3:38 am

Why are their health needs not being addressed? They qualify for national health insurance right?

11 Acropolis7 March 18, 2009 at 6:11 am

#2. Um, It may have been a relative of his…

also Misuda

#4. Well if you look at it factually all forms of modern music from pop,jazz, rock’n'roll, hip-hop,blues,rap have as you quote “inner city ghetto roots”. You just may want to think about that next time you listen any music from those genres.

12 colontos March 18, 2009 at 8:29 am

I doubt that it’s a relative. I don’t believe he has contact with his father’s side of the family.

13 wjk, 검은 머리 외국인 March 18, 2009 at 9:49 am

dude, I don’t care of the consequences.

that video is shit.

14 Brendon Carr (Korea Law Blog) March 18, 2009 at 10:06 am

This is a very interesting video directed by Oscar nominated Canadian-Chinese director Shuibo Wang, all people here should watch it.

Thanks for the recommendation. I thought They Chose China was really interesting, and worth the time to see it.

15 dogbertt March 18, 2009 at 10:11 am

I d/l’ed and watched “They Chose China” and second that thought — it was quite interesting.

16 wjk, 검은 머리 외국인 March 18, 2009 at 10:17 am

ahhhhhhhhhhh arghhhhhhhhhhh

it’s a friggin dishonest crap of lies !!!

ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

17 wjk, 검은 머리 외국인 March 18, 2009 at 10:18 am

Robert, is it safe to say, Fuck Kim Jong Il?

then,

is it safe to say, Fuck C na?

18 wjk, 검은 머리 외국인 March 18, 2009 at 10:19 am

this is propaganda, and not seeing the friggin beam in your own eye at the very worst.

I’m barfing all over. It’s giving me a seizure.

19 misuda March 18, 2009 at 10:30 am

#11
Now that you mention it, the two black dudes do look the same.

also Acropolis7
Music is not a matter of race, how baggy your pants are or indeed even which way you baseball cap faces.

20 Jewook March 18, 2009 at 12:40 pm

Singer AND rapper? Jeckle AND Hyde?

That’s my description not hers. Anyway how does that make her sound bipolar? What about someone who’s an actor/singer?

21 misuda March 18, 2009 at 12:48 pm

Nobody can sing AND rap.
People either have musical ability or not.

22 Andrew March 18, 2009 at 12:51 pm

above states, of mixed race, ” six out of 10 worked as irregular workers”

If you look at this article, 70% of Korean women are irregular workers:

http://joongangdaily.joins.com/article/view.asp?aid=2902103

23 abcdefg March 18, 2009 at 12:54 pm

It just dawned on me. For a devout Christian sexual prissy, wjk sure does curse a lot. F-bombs away, hypocrite.

Why was he unbanned again?

24 misuda March 18, 2009 at 1:04 pm

Andrew, you try fitting in yoga, a swim at the pool, shopping, coffee with friends, shopping, lunch with friends, online daytrading, shopping, golf practice, dinner with friends, a few drinks AND regular employment AND getting home before the husband does.

25 cmm March 18, 2009 at 1:34 pm

@23 I’ve asked why wjk was unbanned several times, but never got a response.

I predict misuda getting banned pretty soon though.

26 cmm March 18, 2009 at 1:43 pm

misuda = swlee?

27 misuda March 18, 2009 at 1:55 pm

Robert threatened to ban me if I didn’t comply with his request to change my avatar, which I immediately did despite the old avatar reappearing a few times due to some software glitch.

Robert also knows my name and email address and can confirm that I am not slwee as cmm and another poster have claimed.

28 David Dodge II March 18, 2009 at 9:45 pm

Yeah, Net Kim saw it “a year ago”. He is so much ahead of the rest of us foreigner garbage. Be they foreigner garbage in the service protecting the peninsula or foreigner garbage not in the service. LOL.

There are several striking differences between the defectors to North Korea and the POW’s in the PRC (actually they were called students). But one important one, is that the black and white soldiers that decided to stay in China married Chinese women. However in opposite, the North Korean government kidnapped foreign women to marry white foreign defectors (to my knowledge there were no black foreigners who chose to stay in North Korea); presumably, because Koreans (unlike the thinking of Americans and Chinese) are a “race”.

My feeling is that Chinese and American people have little opposition to including each other in their respective societies. Whereas, Koreans do. Since, China and America are the largest parties at the table in regards to the fate of the Korean peninsula–

I confidently know we can talk it out.

29 JW March 18, 2009 at 10:08 pm

Please pretty please don’t ban wjk. He is the funniest guy here. If Gerry was even remotely as funny, I wouldn’t say anything about his dokdo screeds either. These are sui generis individuals we are dealing with. Have some respect.

30 David Dodge II March 18, 2009 at 10:24 pm

Brendon,

Are you really an American practicing law in South Korea? That is an interesting story.

I worked as an in-house lawyer for a chaebol for a bit. But, I am surprised that you seem to be there for a while. Perhaps, there is some contracting work with the base. A guy with the DOD once approached me about doing work for the DOD in Korea while I was in there. I like Korea but I forgot about it, in the pursuit of other opportunities.

You should come here to China. There are significant opportunities. I think Dalian would be the best place for you to go, if you have any knowledge of maritime law. If you really like Korea you can return there anytime you want. It is a short boat ride from Dalian to Korea.

Previous post:

Next post: