Open Thread #77

by Robert Koehler on November 29, 2008

in Open Thread

Nice day today. Hope you all enjoy it.

{ 51 comments… read them below or add one }

1 Warren November 29, 2008 at 1:17 pm

First!

Cold and wet day in Daejeon

2 bizzle November 29, 2008 at 1:43 pm

Not yet too cold for a motorcycle ride out of Seoul, but far too windy. It’s a shame, I’m looking at blue skies and white clouds at the moment.

3 ratemyhagwon November 29, 2008 at 3:54 pm

Maybe now is the time to visit LOTTE Department store and do some window shopping.

http://ratemyhagwon.com/2008/1.....apartment/

4 craig November 29, 2008 at 11:40 pm

http://www.thelongestway.com/

Is a very nice photo blog and diary of a German dude, walking from Beijing back home (with a few interludes). So far he has made it Urumqi in western China.

5 choiboi November 29, 2008 at 11:49 pm

I don’t remember the Seoul skyline being so clear as today. I could see Seoul Tower from the highway just off Bundang. Crisp.

6 CactusMcHarris November 30, 2008 at 12:29 am

I was in the Canadian Pooperstore (a Canuck version of Wal-Mart, only without most of the WM negative energy) yesterday and it’s true, it’s true, the minjok do refer to non-Koreans as foreigners, even when the minjok themselves are the foreigners, in a foreign land, surrounded by (mostly) white North Americans.

But, with impeccable logic, it does make sense, kind of – there are Koreans, and there’s everyone else.

We had our first real snowfall here yesterday – not much, but it’s staying.

I’m getting started on the Dokdo book – it’s mostly very slow going, much like War and Peace.

7 JW November 30, 2008 at 12:52 am

http://news.chosun.com/site/da.....00043.html

As a Korean I no longer have any right to talk shit about Chinese take-out.

Sad.

8 CactusMcHarris November 30, 2008 at 2:31 am

As an American continuously learning Korean, I thought it was great that tabang ladies would deliver the coffee and a lesson.

9 baduk November 30, 2008 at 8:31 am

ratemyhagwon,

u r naive. those are fixed. the prise goes to someone’s relative.

10 redneck hickboy November 30, 2008 at 9:15 am

As for Koreans who call us foreigners in our own countries, I do make it a point to politely correct them. I think we all should.

11 paulhewson November 30, 2008 at 10:21 am

It is cold but it is not wet in Dae Jeon today. The sun is shining right now in Doon San.

12 paulhewson November 30, 2008 at 10:22 am

It is cold but it is not wet in Dae Jeon today. The sun is shining right now in Doon San.

13 soondae November 30, 2008 at 10:38 am

Koreans, Chinese, Japanese, and any other people whose written language is influenced by hanja are in ‘foreign land’, which is populated by ‘foreign people’. Still, the nuance should be pointed out. Killer to me is when a 24-year-old introduces himself to me (I’m well well over 24) as Mr. Kim, and yet calls me by my first name. Did Koreans have to adapt the English words Mister and Miss into their language? It is so fucking uncool. ‘Ssi’ would have more than sufficed, just as ’san’ does in Japan.

14 Arghaeri November 30, 2008 at 11:55 am

How!! ssi and san are honorifics used to someone else not to introduce oneself., so doesn’t suffice in Japan cause no one would say it in introducing themselves.

15 Granfalloon November 30, 2008 at 12:52 pm

I kinda disagree. I don’t think English-speakers should be telling Koreans the correct usage of Korean words. I think we should just accept that their word 외국인 does quite mean the same thing as our word “foreigner.” It doesn’t mean that Koreans are wrong. It possibly means that there is an ongoing mistranslation. Seems to me that, according to Cactus’s evidence, 외국인 doesn’t mean “foreigner,” it means “non-Korean,” etymology be damned.

16 Brendon Carr (Korea Law Blog) November 30, 2008 at 1:28 pm

Argh! This is now officially the worst Missouri Tigers football season EVER. We have a good team, with a legitimate star quarterback, and those ninnies managed not only to lose to Texas and Oklahoma State, but today at Arrowhead to the 7-5 Kansas Jayhawks! A 9-3 Tiger football record never stung this bad.

17 NathanB November 30, 2008 at 1:57 pm

I must admit to being a fan of both Cactus McHarris and Granfalloon, and here I think they both have a point. As for “외국인” and “foreigner,” this seems to be a common problem in many linguistic groups that are more or less ethnically homogenous. For example, I find that Chinese students who are new to Canada often refer to Canadians as foreigners, though it is the Chinese students themselves who are the foreigners here.

18 Sonagi November 30, 2008 at 11:52 pm

I kinda disagree. I don’t think English-speakers should be telling Koreans the correct usage of Korean words. I think we should just accept that their word 외국인 does quite mean the same thing as our word “foreigner.”

But they apply the Korean meaning of “외국인” to the English word “foreigner.” An English speaker generally identifies a specific person or persons by their nationality when the nationality is known. Koreans often don’t, reflecting their bipolar worldview of Korean and not Korean.

19 Sonagi November 30, 2008 at 11:56 pm

And Nathan is correct that the Chinese do the same thing although while living in China, I noticed that only really foreign foreigners, aka non-Northeast Asians, were called “laowai” or “waiguoren.” Koreans and Japanese were identified as “hanguoren” and “ribenren.” A Japanese friend once recounted to me of how he was sitting at a dinner table surrounded by Chinese colleagues complaining that there weren’t any foreigners sitting at their table.

20 Darth Babaganoosh December 1, 2008 at 12:28 am

“Seems to me that, according to Cactus’s evidence, 외국인 doesn’t mean “foreigner,” it means “non-Korean,” etymology be damned.”

I would think that it does not translate to “non-Korean”, but more accurately “not of our country”. If I’m in Canada then they are not of my country; they are 외국인.

21 wjk, 검은 머리 외국인 December 1, 2008 at 2:35 am

hey, even white Americans in the US treat white folk like they’re closer to home blood.

when they see a black guy, they have this unsaid guard.

when they see a yellow guy, they have this pre-conceived notion we’re all from China.

who cares if you feel alienated by the term, waekgookin, gaijin, etc?

serves you right.

22 wjk, 검은 머리 외국인 December 1, 2008 at 2:36 am

white folk, meaning anyone who looks like they’re obviously from Europe.

23 baduk December 1, 2008 at 5:50 am

soondae,

“Mr” is not a term of respect in Korea. It designates an office worker, a common helper or a cheap laborer. In a sense, it is even derogatory.

I wonder the person who used it knows the true English meaning of the word.

Don’t assume the extent of a person’s English skill. Koreans speak “Jap English” not the true English.

24 wjk, 검은 머리 외국인 December 1, 2008 at 8:43 am

i’ve had some thoughts.

here they are…

what happened to Ok Sori and Shin Jungah doesn’t show anything positive about how women are treated in Korea.

i don’t think the Italian sausage played as big as a role in Ok Sori’s demise as y’all think.

If there is any sense of legitimacy in existence among Women’s groups in Korea, they should pour down money to help Ok Sori win in court and make an example out of Park Chul to the greatest extent.

Korean laws against illicit drug use are still excellent laws. US should consider adopting it, although I understand there might be some problems with it being constitutional.

25 thekorean December 1, 2008 at 9:34 am

Brendon,

On the other hand, I relish California’s soon-to-be 8-4 (barring some catastrophic happening against UW) that came in a rebuilding year. Sure, that random loss against Maryland hurt (after I drove 4 hours to see it no less!) but overall, a decent season to build on.

Do me a favor and beat OU in the Big 12 championship? I can’t accept the fact that Texas will be passed over Oklahoma when Texas beat Oklahoma in a neutral territory. All will be right if Mizzou beats OU.

26 bizzle December 1, 2008 at 12:10 pm

#24 wjk said: “Korean laws against illicit drug use are still excellent laws. US should consider adopting it…”

That was either poorly played sarcasm or the stupidest thing I’ve read all week.

Here’s the counterargument from police and law enforcement:

http://www.leap.cc/cms/index.php

27 Linkd December 1, 2008 at 1:55 pm

Michael Breen redefines Public Relations (all headlines Bloomberg):

Lone Star’s Korea Exchange Win May Prove Short-Lived
“Michael Breen, whose public relations firm represents Lone Star in Seoul, declined to comment…”

HSBC’s Bid for Korea Exchange Gets Boost From Regulatory Review
“Michael Breen, president of Insight Communications Consultants which represents Lone Star in Seoul, wasn’t immediately reachable for comment…”

South Korea Stocks Decline; Daewoo Shipbuilding Leads Retreat
“Michael Breen, president of Insight Communications Consultants, which represents Lone Star in Seoul, said he had no immediate comment…”

HSBC to Negotiate Lower Price for Korea Exchange Bank
“Michael Breen, president of Insight Communications Consultants, which represents Lone Star in Seoul, said he had no immediate comment…”

Lone Star May Sue Korea Over Exchange Bank Sale, Munhwa Says
“Michael Breen, president of Insight Communications Consultants, which represents Lone Star in Seoul, declined to comment on the report…”

Looks like a tough job, PR does.

28 Linkd December 1, 2008 at 1:56 pm

PS – just taking the piss, old boy. You know we love you.

29 eujin December 1, 2008 at 4:32 pm

I don’t pretend to understand what is going on in Thailand, but I think it reminds us that whatever its shortcomings, Korea’s development is still a model for many countries. One of the things that they have been talking about in Thailand is accusations that the government’s supporters are relatively uneducated and because of this, not all seats in the assembly should be directly elected. This is certainly interesting in the light of many things that have been said around here lately. They are still locking up ex-Presidents in Taiwan and talking about a “Gloria Forever” constitution in the Philippines.

30 Brendon Carr (Korea Law Blog) December 1, 2008 at 8:02 pm

Korea’s democratic facade over the kleptocracy seems to be very well-rooted indeed.

31 baduk December 2, 2008 at 1:53 am

eujin,

Korea was under American influence from 1945 to 1980. Some “American” democracy, one vote for one person for example, rubbed off.

It is funny that nobody in Korea is willing to admit this. I mean good American influence. Now, Korean Commies taught everything about America is bad. And, some Europe-educated wimps have chimed in.

The truth, however, is America worked for Korea. It worked through Christianity. That changed Korea. Whenever there was a big conflict, churches including both Protestants and Catholics steered Korea from a big killing field.

And, in fact, that is how America avoided racial war in America as well. Through churches.

This is not possible in non-Christian nations. Buddhists can peacefully kill other people. Nothing to lose; the dead reborn. Some even to an upper being.

Religion has much to do with how nations behave.

32 CactusMcHarris December 2, 2008 at 3:09 am

#10,

And to do so in Korean, of course, so that at least the point is delivered.

#15,

I have no evidence, but I think that it would help Koreans-in-foreign-lands’ transitions if they stopped using that phrase. Even my Korean isn’t quite yet rusty enough to not note that the phrase ‘outside country person’ is, when used by Koreans outside of Korea, means not Korean, i.e. the greatest folk on earth…..just kidding.

33 WangKon936 December 2, 2008 at 4:23 am

# 16,

Hey Brendon… at least you are not a USC fan. We, year after year, have the best team in college football. We end up losing once to a mediocre team and the BCS never forgives us and we have to hear our coach whine about it for the second half of the season… :P

34 dogbertt December 2, 2008 at 5:27 am

University of Spoiled Children

35 WangKon936 December 2, 2008 at 6:27 am

University of Super Connections… ;)

36 Sperwer December 2, 2008 at 8:48 am

I don’t pretend to understand what is going on in Thailand…

Then why don’t you stop pretending you have anything worth saying about what anyone has to “learn from Korea” and refrain from otiose and foolish speculative twaddle on that non-subject.

37 CactusMcHarris December 2, 2008 at 10:53 am

#36,

Your comment smacks a bit of the out-and-outer – perhaps you’ve not had a good day.

I’ve found Eujin’s comments anything but otiose – perhaps you mistook her posting for someone else’s.

As to twaddle, I wish you had reviewed your posting – any major dude or gal can see that you’ve created a murky puddle of gratuitous meanness that needn’t have been posted.

38 Sonagi December 2, 2008 at 11:14 am

Sperwer’s from Detroit, home of the 0-16 Lions, governed by a succession of corrupt, inept leaders, located across from Windsor, Canada, a boring shithole that actually looks scenic compared to the rusting smokestacks across the river.

39 Linkd December 2, 2008 at 12:03 pm

Time to start making your Xmas shopping lists!!

Gershon of New York makes a cutter out of a warthog tusk, with 14-karat yellow gold hardware. Each one is handmade, and there are no two alike. It comes available with engraving or diamond detailing, as well as in a pink gold version, created by mixing alloys with pure gold (€1,227; gershon limited.com). But the Dunhill Metta Catharina cigar-connoisseur kit is a cut above the rest. Each set includes a travel humidor, a circular cigar cutter and cutter pouch, a mini cigar case and a Turbo lighter—all presented in a leather-bound case. The cutter and pouch are made from 220-year-old reindeer leather recovered from the wreckage of the Danish ship Frau Metta Catharina von Flensburg, which was protected by black mud. Dunhill retrieved enough of the leather to make 15 limited-edition sets (€4,937; dunhill.com).

Bet one of those babies would put some ho-ho in Sperwer’s stocking.

40 CactusMcHarris December 2, 2008 at 1:38 pm

Since it is an open thread….and I reckon that Sperwer’s taken enough chiding…

Can anyone help me out with the ability to type Hangul? I’ve got the East Asian package downloaded, I have the choice of Korean or English in the language bar (and have chosen Korean, no pun intended), but I’m still getting Roman letters – egads.

Any advice on this (or anything else your heart desires) would be appreciated.

41 Sperwer December 2, 2008 at 3:06 pm

Linkd: I don’t smoke, but I know a place in Key Marathon with barstools upholstered in tanned whale penis skin on which I bet you would like to sit.

42 Sperwer December 2, 2008 at 3:29 pm

Sonagi:

When I lived there the auto factories (where all my family worked) were running at full tilt, and the city was rich. The Lions were quarterbacked by Bobby Layne and Earl Morrall, with Yale Larry, Terry Barr and Hopalong Cassasdy as backs/receivers; Joe Schmidt ran the defense with Alex Karras and Roger Brown at DT, Wayne Walker at LB and Night Train Lane @ CB, and Dick LeBeau in the secondary. They won the Thanksgiving Day game against green bay, which was the only game that mattered, more often than not. Al Kaline, Jim Bunning, Red Wilson, Eddie Yost, Hank Aguirre,Norm Cash, and Rocky Colavito played for the Tigers and Gordie Howe played with a Red Wings team captained by Ted Lindsay with Terry Sawchuck in goal and Alex Delvecchio and Norm Ullman also in the front line. Basketball didn’t count. Glory days, sister.

43 Sperwer December 2, 2008 at 3:32 pm

Cactus:

Eujin does generally post decent, even good stuff. I was only calling her on the quoted drivel, which isn’t worthy of her.

44 Linkd December 2, 2008 at 4:13 pm
45 eujin December 2, 2008 at 4:50 pm

Slow day on the Hole today?

At the risk of obscuring an already obscure point, I note that Michael Howard, former Home Secretary and former leader of Her Majesty’s Opposition has commented on the recent political scandal in the UK, “This is the sort of thing that led to the start of the civil war,”.

http://www.iht.com/articles/20.....ritain.php

That’s right folks, the English Civil War of 1642. Plus ca change…

46 abcdefg December 2, 2008 at 6:04 pm

“Otiose” must be Detroit vernacular for “I’m an SAT geek”, or something. I am always reminded of those long vocab lists I’d study as a kid when I read a Sperwer post here.

47 Hwarang December 2, 2008 at 9:21 pm

Cactus, if you’re running Vista, one way is to left click on the EN and scroll to KO Korean, then left click on the Roman letter “A” on the toolbar so it changes to “가.” If you have the cursor in a text box you should be able to type in Hangul.

48 MrMao December 2, 2008 at 10:18 pm

Check out the pre-Christmas rush OUT of Korea on eslcafe.com’s Buy n’Sell board.

“Everything must go! Free furniture! Foster dog needs home! Hell, the dog died so come take the crate for free! Buy my couch and I’ll throw in a Trek mountain bike! Kawasaki motorcycle! Macbook Air! Take my apartment in Hongdae!”

Looks a bit like the Titanic to me. I see people jettisoning some valuable stuff. I wonder why.

Strictly non-scientific poll.

49 Sperwer December 2, 2008 at 10:22 pm

I’m genuinely flattered Linkd, (so I won’t suggest seeing about getting you work as a fluffer. ;) ) But I see your point; I do need some sort of gimmick to accompany me on my periodic detours and frolics into curmudgeondum. A stogie would do for a WC Fields, but I’m no longer fat enough. And I no longer drink – not much anyway – so that rules out Doc Holiday (booze and his saloon ladies – damn) and Ambrose Bierce (booze and Mexican saloon cooze – damn). I’ll have to think on it.

[BTW the cetacean preputiam carapaced bar stools actually exist at the Key Marathon Marina - or they did in 1985, which was the last time I was there. They were commissioned by John Theurer, who was then the owner. His family started out as carriage makers in Central Europe, then New York City and when John ran the company they made marine cargo containers and trailers (as in tractor-trailers). He was a colorful character.]

What can I say Mr. Alphabet? I was terrible at math, so I overcompensated.

50 thekorean December 3, 2008 at 12:17 am

Cactus,

while being in Korean language bar, you should see something like this: KO A [Chinese character]. At this point, try pressing ALT on the right side of your keyboard. The language bar should now say KO 가 [Chinese character]. Now you are ready to type Korean.

Wangkon,

I had a friend from Univ. of South Carolina — apparently the South Carolina Gamecocks get all pissy about the fact that their USC is older than Univ. of Spoiled Chil… err Univ. of Southern California. So he had a shirt that said (saw this myself): “Before there were Trojans, there were Cocks.” Priceless.

51 WangKon936 December 3, 2008 at 3:46 am

Yes… I heard of *that* USC. The WAY overshadowed USC.

Ain’t our fault that the Trojan is bigger than the cock…

Previous post: A Place For Hate and Ideology in Modern History…

Next post: Gyopo out to reform DC schools