Marmot’s Vacation Day 1: Road to No Gun Ri

by Robert Koehler on August 5, 2008

in Korean History, Photos of Korea, ROK-US Issues

Double Railroad Bridge, Nogeun-ni
The double railway bridge at Nogeun-ni (No Gun Ri), where US troops killed an undetermined number of refugees in late July, 1950.

OK, so with my well-earned (if I may say so myself) week vacation, I find myself on the road in lovely Yeongdong-gun, Chungcheongbuk-do, where I’ve come to check out a couple historical and architectural sites of interest in the area before I move on to elsewhere.

Okcheon Samyangni Catholic Church

Okcheon Samyangni Catholic Church

OK, this was supposed to be one of the highlights of my trip. The beautiful Okcheon Samyangni Catholic Church in Okcheon-gun, Chungcheongbuk-do was one of the first properties to be listed on the Cultural Heritage Administration’s Registered Cultural Properties List when the list was promulgated in 2002.

Unfortunately, when I arrived in Okcheon, I learned it was undergoing renovation. Shit. Well, at least I got to take a photo of the steeple.

The church’s history goes back over 100 years, but the current structure was completed in 1955. French missionaries founded the church, but in 1953, administration of the local dioceses was transferred to the Maryknoll Fathers of the United States. The church you see today is believed to have been designed by Ralph Deblanc, an American Catholic friar in Cheongju who just so happened to have majored in civil engineering at university, a useful skill set in Korea at the time. When it’s not covered in scaffolding, it’s really quite pretty.

Old Schoolhouse of Okcheon Jukhyang Elementary School

Okcheon Jukhyang Elementary School

Inner Hallway, Okcheon Jukhyang Elementary School

Well, they certainly don’t build ‘em like this anymore.

This pretty little Japanese-built wooden schoolhouse was built in 1936, and is remarkably well-preserved. Listed as Registered Cultural Property No. 57, the old schoolhouse is now used by the elementary school as a museum. It has three classrooms, which now house an Okcheon-gun educational history exhibit, a Jukhyang Elementary School history exhibit, and an alumni donation exhibit.

Coincidentally, this schoolhouse produced a number of notable figures, including Catholic poet Jeong Ji-yong (believed to have defected to North Korea during the Korean War) and late First Lady Yuk Young-soo.

Old Classroom, Okcheon Jukhyang Elementary School

You know, I’ve actually taught in a classroom just like this one.

Boxed Lunches, Okcheon Jukhyang Elementary School

Nothing says “nostalgia” like some dosirak on a wood-burning stove.

Attendance Box, Okcheon Jukhyang Elementary School

Nobody playing hookie, I hope.

Old Computers, Okcheon Jukhyang Elementary School

Some 1980s vintage Lucky Goldstar (now LG) computers. Probably can’t run GTA San Andreas on them, but on the positive side, you probably can’t run Windows Vista on them, either.

Old Maps, Okcheon Jukhyang Elementary School

Hmmm… old classroom maps. Somewhere, a tear comes to Baduk’s eye.

1970s Textbooks, Okcheon Jukhyang Elementary School

Colonial Textbooks, Okcheon Jukhyang Elementary School

Some old textbooks — the ones on the top are from the 60s and 70s, while the ones on the bottom are from the Japanese colonial era.

I should offer a word of thanks to one of the teachers of at Jukhyang Elementary School, who was kind enough to open up the old school house and show me around.

Pagoda, Okcheon Jukhyang Elementary School

Leave it up to the Japanese to remove an ancient stone pagoda from an old temple site to use as an elementary school garden ornament. Guess I can’t fault them that much — they’d hardly be the last administrators in Korea to do play “Relocate the Cultural Treasure to Somewhere it Doesn’t Belong.”

Nogeun-ni (No Gun Ri)

Nogeun-ni Incident Site

Nogeun-ni Incident Site

Double Railroad Bridge, Nogeun-ni

Double Railroad Bridge, Nogeun-ni

Double Railroad Bridge, Nogeun-ni

Double Railroad Bridge, Nogeun-ni

This was the ultimate destination of Day 1.

The Japanese-built double railroad bridge at Nogeun-ni needs no introduction, but just in case, here it goes — depending on whom you ask, the US military, acting on orders to shoot refugees trying to cross American lines, either intentionally slaughtered over 200 civilian refugees under and around the bridge on July 26—29, 1950 in what is now called the No Gun Ri Massacre, or a chaotic battlefield situation combined with North Korean infiltration of refugee columns and inexperience on the part of US troops in the midst of a panicked retreat led to the accidental killing of a much fewer number of refugees near the bridge.

For their work in reporting the massacre, AP’s Choe Sang-hun, Charles J. Hanley and Martha Mendoza were awarded a Pulitzer in 2000 — the link has all their pieces on the subject. Their report was not without controversy — GI Korea criticizes AP at length, so give it a read. Another guy who was a tad upset was OhMyNews founder Oh Yeon Ho, who wrote about the incident for the Korean magazine “Mal” six years before Choe, Hanley and Mendoza “discovered” the incident.

Anyway, the Wikipedia page (linked above) details the controversy over the incident. Frankly, I have no idea what happened; the only thing I think I know is that AP, the US military, survivors groups and the Korean Truth and Reconciliation Committee don’t really know what happened, either. And given the chaotic situation at the time, I doubt very much we ever will know.

Coincidentally, if you’re travelling to Nogeun-ni (it’s a 12,000 won taxi ride from downtown Yeongdong-gun) hoping to speak with survivors and their families, you’re going to the wrong town. The villagers who were attacked were from Jugong-ni, which is a couple minutes up the road to Yeongdong from Nogeun-ni.

Bullet Mark, Double Railroad Bridge, Nogeun-ni

There are many such bullet holes in and around the bridge.

T-Shirt, Double Railroad Bridge, Nogeun-ni

A T-shirt left by a visiting group. The anniversary of the attack was just last week.

Nogeun-ni Incident Point

Much as the sign would suggest.

Nogeun-ni Double Railroad Bridge

The double railroad bridge has been designated Registered Cultural Property No. 59. Say what you will about the Japanese, but they did erect some pretty pieces of civil engineering.

Painting, Nogeun-ni Double Railroad Bridge

A painting near the bridge, with US warplanes bombing and strafing the refugees on the railroad tracks while US soldiers machine-gun refugees hiding under the bridge. According to the description of the incident given at the site, the residents of Jugong-ni were eventually led to the area around the bridge by the US Army after they were ordered to evacuate their village. Then at noon on July 26, the refugees on the tracks were bombed and strafed by the USAF, while from that afternoon to the morning of July 29, US troops machine-gunned refugees seeking shelter under the bridge.

That’s what it says, anyway.

Explanation of Nogeun-ni Incident

I’m no military science major, but I don’t believe the F-15 was operational as of July 1950.

Like the DMZ, the area around Nogeun-ni has a serene beauty to it — lots of green hills and valleys full of fruit orchards. The region is particularly renowned for its grapes, which thrive thanks to the dramatic morning—afternoon temperature differences. Lots of dragonflies around the bridge, too.

A memorial park is currently being constructed around the bridge, and should be complete by 2010.

Nogeun-ni is particularly relevant now with the Korean Truth and Reconciliation Commission releasing Sunday the results of its investigation into another alleged mass killing by US troops during the war, this time at the Gokgyegul Stream in Danyang, Chungcheongbukdo on Jan 20, 1951.

{ 1 trackback }

Back Home at Last | The Marmot's Hole
August 11, 2008 at 2:43 am

{ 21 comments… read them below or add one }

1 Benicio74 August 5, 2008 at 10:03 pm

GI Korea has an excellent write up on some of the major inconsistencies involving alleged massacres/strafings/mass killings. A lot of the evidence just doesn’t add up:
http://rokdrop.com/2008/07/26/.....no-gun-ri/

2 Richard August 5, 2008 at 10:11 pm

Thanks for the pics. I especially liked the stove with the doshirak. MY goodensss, that brought back memories of very cold winters in our middle school and the frozen hands of the 70 plus students crammed in a room wearing their black military style uniforms.
Nerv ever gave off enough heat and the teachers lounge was no better.
And my almost daily delivery for lunch of chachamyoung or pokimpop. and the sharing of REAL homeamde kimchi from my fellow teachers.
Good times.

3 Robert Koehler August 5, 2008 at 10:42 pm

GI Korea does some good work, but I have to confess, I’m not sure if I find relying on forensic evidence 50 years after the fact so convincing, either. Who knows what could have happened in the meantime. Which is not to say, of course, that I find AP’s “atrocity mongering” or the Monday morning generalship of the university leftists on the Korean Truth and Reconciliation Committee any more convincing.

4 Michael August 5, 2008 at 10:47 pm

Seems like you’re on a working vacation…good photos. No Gun Ri (no matter what actually happened there) is tragic and as you said, exactly what happened there might never be clear. All you can hope for is that the relative peace continues.

Anyway, have a good one.

5 Robert Koehler August 5, 2008 at 11:10 pm

Working vacation? Hah! This is what I do for fun!

6 dogbert August 5, 2008 at 11:25 pm

Your vacation activities seem indistinguishable from your work. That’s dedication!

7 globalvillageidiot August 6, 2008 at 5:13 am

Great photos.

8 rich August 6, 2008 at 6:09 am

Nice pics,. I have some circa 1971 all on super 8 film though, but so many changes. So, whats with this Korea truth bs. Why are’nt Koreans calmmering about the Korean soldiers killing their own people especially down south where the communist sympathiser were???

9 user-81 August 6, 2008 at 6:52 am

@rich re #8:
“Why are’nt Koreans calmmering about the Korean soldiers killing their own people especially down south where the communist sympathiser were???”

What makes you so sure they aren’t?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/T.....f_Korea%29

10 Tripod August 6, 2008 at 8:00 am

“I’m no military science major, but I don’t believe the F-15 was operational as of July 1950.”

I really doubt someone was being sloppy when they picked that picture. It was a deliberate choice, in my opinion.

11 soondae August 6, 2008 at 9:57 am

Interesting, as we have the My Lai Massacre site on the agenda for next week. Regardless of the truth factor, in war shit happens. Reasons to stay out of civil wars.

12 ghost of tiny August 6, 2008 at 11:12 am

What a beautiful hallway in that school.

13 Get a Job, Son! August 6, 2008 at 2:09 pm

“I’m no military science major, but I don’t believe the F-15 was operational as of July 1950.”

Did I see that same F-15 fighter on one of the ancient Dokdo maps too?

14 GI Korea August 6, 2008 at 5:09 pm

Robert nice pics of the site.

Let me just clarify one statement you made though, I don’t rely on just 50 year old forensic evidence. The forensic evidence is all part of the documentary evidence, imagery analysis, and veteran witness statements that all contradict the established No Gun Ri mythology.

There is much more evidence to support the critics claims of what happened at NGR then relying on the AP’s ever changing Korean witness statements and testimony from GIs who were not at NGR.

Anyway it is no secret what happened at No Gun Ri. This statement from a GI witness that was proven to be at No Gun Ri unlike the AP GI witnesses that were later proven to not be there best sums up what happened:

“The civilians started coming down the railroad tracks, on paths on both sides of the tracks… The front ones, there were like maybe 15 or 20 of them, and they were getting thicker beyond that. Somebody said, “Fire over their heads for a warning.” … I got out of my hole with about 30 other guys; we all had M-1s. Now, we had one machine gun up on the railroad tracks and another air cooled machine gun on the right. Well when we fired over their heads they panicked. … That’s when some of them started to run towards us. We were firing over them all this time.

Then somebody yelled, “We’re being fired at,” then there was a bunch that started shooting into the refugees … This all happened in a minute, but it all came out when we panicked ‘cause we thought we were getting shot at.

There was a lieutenant that was running down to that group I was with. I saw this little girl that was sort of in front, she was maybe four or five years old and she was coming down the track I shot towards her and she fell. Well, this lieutenant ran out there and picked up this little girl. Why … I can’t tell you. That’s why the lieutenant was yelling, “Cease fire,” and he was running. She was out there in front, by herself, and flailing here arms and throwing her arms down.

After the cease-fire I stayed where I was, maybe 10-15 yards from the track, and maybe six or eight guys went down the tracks from the group that I was with, and a few went down from on top of the tracks. One of the guys went down there and searched a few of the bodies, he … found a body with a burp gun, and he yelled, “Here’s the goddamned gun,” and he held it straight up and slammed it down on the tracks.”

Buddy Wenzel
7th Cav Vet at No Gun Ri

15 user-81 August 6, 2008 at 5:20 pm

I don’t know much about firearms, but isn’t a burp gun a German submachine gun? Would it be common for a North Korean soldier or guerrilla to have a burp gun?

16 mizar5 August 7, 2008 at 1:33 am

Only the Marmot would vacation at No Gun Ri.

17 Netizen Kim August 7, 2008 at 1:38 am

Only the Marmot would vacation at No Gun Ri.

LOL! That was the funniest shit you ever said.

18 dogbert August 7, 2008 at 1:42 am

I’ve got to hand it to the Marmot and his mad husband skillz … in my house, “Honey, guess where we’re going on our vacation this year? — Paris, what … ? No, silly! We’re going to NO GUN RI, yeah, w00t!” would go over like the proverbial lead balloon.

19 GI Korea August 9, 2008 at 9:35 am

@15, a “burp gun” was a common GI slang term for the guns used by the North Koreans and Chinese during the Korean War.

20 WangKon936 August 9, 2008 at 9:37 am

a.k.a Stalin’s banjo…

21 WangKon936 August 9, 2008 at 9:39 am

btw GI… I’m a fan of your blog. Keep up the good work.

Previous post: Anti-Americanism you say?

Next post: “How Much is That Doggie in the Test Tube?”