Jeongdong: the Coming of the West

UPDATE: For more on the history of the Jeongdong neighborhood (as well as some very cool old photographs), check out Gusts of Popular Feeling’s posts (I, II) on the area.

ORIGINAL POST: As some of you may know, I assist with a monthly walking tour of Seoul’s architecture, hosted by the Seoul Foundation for Arts and Culture. Anyway, on Sunday, we took about 30 people—mostly Koreans, with a couple of foreigners—to the historic Jeongdong neighborhood to tour around some of Korea’s earliest examples of Western architecture.

Jeongdong—the pleasant neighborhood to the west of the Deoksugung Palace—is where many of Seoul’s first foreign legations, schools and churches were built in the late 19th century/early 20th century. As such, the area was a major entry point for the introduction of foreign culture into Korea—Seoul’s first Protestant churches, first modern schools and first modern hotel were all built there. As the foreign legation district—and located as it was right next to the center of political power of the Daehan Empire, the Duksugung Palace—the neighborhood was also the venue for much of the intrigue that marked the end of the Joseon era.

Today, the area retains a somewhat exotic foreign charm, and a good number of historical buildings—many designed by Americans, Brits, Russians and other Dead White Guys—still remain.

Modern Cultural Properties, Jeongdong

Evidence Seoul is taking greater pride in its modern architectural treasures—you can find these all along path that follows the stone wall, or doldam, or the Deoksugung Palace. Just a quick note about Deoksugung Palace’s famous doldam-gil—many of you are probably familiar with the story of the lovers who walk along the stone wall but separate at the end. The reason for that story is that the Family Court used to be located along the path.

Seoul Museum of Art

Seoul Museum of Art

The Seoul Museum of Art. Built by the Japanese in 1928 as the Keijo Court House, this building would become the model for many other public buildings built during the colonial era—see for example the former main building of Seoul National University in Daehangno, now used as the office of Arts Council Korea.

After Liberation, the building became the Supreme Court of Korea. In 1995, however, the Supreme Court moved to Seocho-dong south of the river, and the structure was extensively remodeled for use as the Seoul Museum of Art. All that remains of the old building is the facade, but as you can see above, what a facade it it!

Pai Chai Hak Dang

This is the East Hall of what was the Pai Chai Hak Dang, Korea’s first modern intermediate school (and the predecessor of Pai Chai Middle and High School). The school was founded in 1885 by American Methodist missionary Henry Gerhard Appenzeller, who also founded Chungdong First Methodist Church just down the street. The American imprint (and that of the British and Russians) in Jeongdong is quite strong—the Pai Chai Hak Dang, First Methodist Church and Ewha Hak Dang were all founded by American missionaries, and of course there was the old American Legation, the site of the current U.S. ambassador’s residence.

Chungdong First Methodist Church

Chungdong First Methodist Church

Henry Gerhard Appenzeller, Chungdong First Methodist Church Chungdong First Methodist Church

Chungdong First Methodist Church, Korea’s first Methodist church. The current church dates back to 1897. A cute little American-style Gothic church, it’s a major symbol of the introduction of American culture to Korea. Interestingly enough, at least for me, it also published Korea’s first monthly magazine,”Gyohoe,” in 1889, with the goal of propagating liberal thought in Korea. It also opened Korea’s first summer bible school in 1922.

Salvation Army Headquarters

Salvation Army Headquarters

The Salvation Army Headquarters, completed in 1928. A massive neoclassical structure, it was considered one of Seoul’s 10 greatest buildings when it was built. Hidden away as it is along the road that passes in front of the U.S. ambassador’s residence, it doesn’t see a lot of visitors. Which is a shame, really, because it is quite impressive.

Seoul Anglican Cathedral

Seoul Anglican Cathedral

Seoul Anglican Cathedral Seoul Anglican Cathedral

Seoul Anglican Cathedral—hands-down the most beautiful church in Seoul, and, IMHO, the most beautiful building in the city, period. It’s also Seoul’s only Romanesque-style church, and is built in the shape of a Latin cross. Oddly enough, when it was first consecrated in 1926, it was only half-completed, really. The church would have to wait until 1996 to attain its current glory—the expansion was conducted based on the original design plan, which was discovered in a museum in Lexington in 1993. The interior of the church, BTW, is absolutely spectacular (unfortunately, there were functions going on at the time, so I couldn’t take any photos), as is the church’s crypt, which is home to an actual Dead White Guy, the third Anglican Bishop of Seoul (and cathedral founder), Mark Napier Trollope. The second bishop, Arthur Turner, coincidentally might have been the man who introduced football to the Korean Peninsula. The first bishop, of course, was Charles John Corfe.

Retreat Garden, Seoul Anglican Cathedral

We also got a quick unscheduled peak at the beautiful retreat garden behind the Anglican Cathedral, which I was told—and this I did not verify, so if you know better, feel free to correct me—is owned by the British Embassy.

Seoul Municipal Council

Seoul Municipal Hall. I look at it, and still can’t believe it was built in 1935. Originally, it served as a cultural hall for Seoul’s masses, and was modeled on a cultural hall in Hibiya, Tokyo. After Liberation, it was used as the National Assembly Building until the current one was built in Yeouido. It’s now used as the meeting place of Seoul Municipal Council.

Azaleas, Deoksugung Palace

Deoksugung Palace

Changing of the Guard, Deoksugung Palace

Jeonggwanheon, Deoksugung Palace

Changing of the Guard, Deoksugung Palace Deoksugung Palace

Hannyeongjeon, Deoksugung Palace Azaleas, Deoksugung Palace

The Deoksugung Palace—one of my favorite places to snap photos, especially in spring when the azaleas are in full bloom. The Deoksugung, of course, was the center of much of the drama that characterized the rise and fall of the Daehan Empire at the start of the 20th century. Architecturally, it’s interesting in that it’s the first of Seoul’s palaces to incorporate Western-style buildings. One of those buildings—and certainly one of the most quirky of Seoul’s palace structures—is the fourth photo, the Jeonggwanheon Pavilion. Designed by the fascinating Aleksey Seredin-Sabatin, a Russian architect in the employ of the Korean government, the pavilion was built as a rest and relaxation place for Emperor Gojong, who reportedly enjoyed lounging on the pavilion with a good cup of coffee, then a rare foreign import.

Jungmyeongjeon, Deoksugung Palace

The Jungmyeongjeon, built in 1900. This royal library/banquet hall for foreign envoys–designed by the afore mentioned Seredin-Sabatin—was the first Western-style building built on the grounds of a Korean palace. Historically, it’s quite important as the site where the Protectorate Treaty of 1905 was signed, under which Korea signed away its foreign policy decision-making to Japan. Originally part of the Deoksugung, the stone wall separating it from the palace was built during the colonial era. Recently, however, the Cultural Heritage Administration placed the building back within the grounds of the Deoksugung—at least administratively.

Simpson Hall, Ewha Girls High School

Ewha Girls High School’s Simpson Hall (built in 1915), all that is left of the original Ewha Hak Dang, which was founded in 1886 by American Methodist Episcopal missionary Mary F. Scranton. Ewha Hak Dang would eventually grow into Ewha Middle and High School and, of course, Ewha Womens University, the world’s largest women’s university.

With its red brick and keystones, the school would serve as the model of many other Christian schools built during the first half of the 20th century.

Interestingly, on the grounds of Ewha Girls High School is the site of the former Sontag Hotel (designed by, oddly enough, Seredin-Sabatin), which was Seoul’s first Western-style hotel and a major hang-out (and scheming venue) of late Joseon-era Seoul’s foreign community. If you read Korean, you’ll definitely want to check out this blog post on the hotel’s founder, Antoinette Sontag, and the history of the hotel.

Old Russian Legation Tower

Ah, the tower of the former Russian Legation, which was built in 1890 by—you guessed it—Seredin-Sabatin. As the representatives of one of the imperial powers with the most at stake geopolitically in Korea, the Russian Legation was quite a busy place in the years prior to the Russo-Japanese War. In fact, following the assassination of his queen, the Empress Myeongseong, Emperor Gojong and the Crown Prince fled to the Russian Legation, where they stayed for a full year. Unfortunately, most of the original compound was destroyed during the Korean War.

NOTE: I know I promised last week’s Catholic churches. I’ll try to post them tonight.

28 Comments

  1. michael your flag
    Posted April 23, 2007 at 4:56 pm | Permalink

    Wow, the Anglican Cathedral is really stunning. Haven’t poked around in the area behind the palace so now I’ll definitely check it out. Thanks for the photos.

  2. seoulmilk your flag
    Posted April 23, 2007 at 4:58 pm | Permalink

    thank you robert. that’s awesome! as for the story behind doldam-gil, i’ve always wondered about its root. ironically, my current girlfriend and i started dating after walking down the street.

  3. hardyandtiny your flag
    Posted April 23, 2007 at 5:18 pm | Permalink

    Great post!

  4. railwaycharm your flag
    Posted April 23, 2007 at 5:33 pm | Permalink

    Marmot,

    You have reminded me of the beauty that is hiding in plain sight in this concrete jungle. Thanks!

  5. gbnhj your flag
    Posted April 23, 2007 at 6:51 pm | Permalink

    Thanks for the great photos and info. It’s believe that Seoul Municipal Hall was built in 1935 - I guess I’ll stop cursing it’s coldness and try to reconsider its place in the skyline.

    Robert, any chance that you’ll be guiding groups through this area again? If so, please give us a heads-up. I’d love to learn more about Seoul’s architecture.

  6. Posted April 23, 2007 at 7:37 pm | Permalink

    You’ve outdone yourself, Robert. I really hope that you’re at least thinking about putting all of this together and into a book. I’d definitely buy it.

  7. Posted April 23, 2007 at 7:38 pm | Permalink

    Does anyone else get this error right after they post a comment?

    Regex ID: 4880 () appears to be an invalid regex string! Please fix it in the Blacklist control panel.
    Regex ID: 4879 () appears to be an invalid regex string! Please fix it in the Blacklist control panel.
    Regex ID: 4878 () appears to be an invalid regex string! Please fix it in the Blacklist control panel.

  8. Posted April 23, 2007 at 7:55 pm | Permalink

    Strangely enough, even I get it sometimes, Nomad. Since the comments are going up, I haven’t worried about it too much. I gather it’s a problem with Spam Karma. I’ll have to look into it eventually.

  9. Posted April 23, 2007 at 9:17 pm | Permalink

    First class stuff. I really wish I could have made it.

  10. Posted April 23, 2007 at 10:30 pm | Permalink

    Great post! I wrote a bit about the history of this area last summer and took some photos thinking of doing something similar, but some of these buildings, like Jungmyeongjeon, I knew nothing about, and I never came across Pai Chai building. Thanks for posting these!

  11. robert neff your flag
    Posted April 23, 2007 at 11:29 pm | Permalink

    Great photographs….always enjoy your eye for the buildings and the surroundings and the backgrounds were very good. I have always loved Sontag Hotel and hope to have something up on it within the next couple of weeks.

    Seredin-Sabatin was definitely a character, but he wasn’t the only architect involved in building designs in this section of the city.

    Again - great pictures and a great posting…

  12. Maddlew your flag
    Posted April 24, 2007 at 12:51 am | Permalink

    Very nice photos Robert. I happened to work right across the street from the Anglican Church at the Language Teaching Research Center. It is breathtaking and they are meticulous in its upkeep. There’s a cloister of nuns on the east side who do some great work with the lepers of Korea. Extremely nice folks. We used to throw in a manwon a month each and wander around occasionally. It always felt like we were being transported to another world just walking by it every day.

  13. robert neff your flag
    Posted April 24, 2007 at 12:56 am | Permalink

    Quick question - every time I go and try to take a picture of the Russian Legation (Tower) I am stopped by the riot police - who insist that it is a restricted area. Either I look like a threat or not threatening enough.

  14. robert neff your flag
    Posted April 24, 2007 at 12:57 am | Permalink

    guess I should have added the question: Don’t you ever get stopped for taking photographs at some of these places?

  15. Maddlew your flag
    Posted April 24, 2007 at 1:02 am | Permalink

    Oh yeah, I don’t know if they still do but they used to have little lunch time concerts over there on Tuesdays during the warm months with free food. I always thought the food was for the needy but you’d always see the business folk from around the area grubbing out. It was kinda funny watching those church people swaying to some new Korean sounds.

  16. Posted April 24, 2007 at 1:17 am | Permalink

    On the street between Deoksu palace and the US ambassador’s residence, the riot police stopped me from taking photos as well. It’s a bit silly - it’s a road with high walls on both sides, and if I really wanted to see inside, there’s always Google Earth.

  17. Posted April 24, 2007 at 2:19 am | Permalink

    Robert, this is superb stuff. Thank you very much. As Nomad mentioned above and at least 3 of us mentioned on the Gupodong post, please seriously consider putting out a book on the sort of late-Joseon/colonial-period, foreign-influenced Korean architecture you specialize so well in photographing.

  18. skookum your flag
    Posted April 24, 2007 at 5:31 am | Permalink

    This article is so very interesting. I have taken many photos of Korean churches and one thing I always wondered about was the bright red or orange steeples on some churches (Methodist?) They didn’t seem to fit in with the rest of the design. Anyone know the story about them?

    Also, I’ve heard that some Korean churches were inspired by Albert Speer’s designs. Does anyone have a link to that, or know anything….

  19. Grumpy your flag
    Posted April 24, 2007 at 9:26 am | Permalink

    Robert,

    Perhaps you should start a new photo/history blog with a book deal and do a re-make a la “Through Gates of Seoul”.

  20. michael your flag
    Posted April 24, 2007 at 9:31 am | Permalink

    Marmot, here’s some unasked-for advice: take a lot of interior shots as well, whenever you can. It’s also interesting to see what’s inside the churches :)

  21. lirelou your flag
    Posted April 24, 2007 at 11:02 am | Permalink

    A somewhat relate post. Far Outliers has a post on “how Korea became illegal in 1907″, detailing Korea’s failure to mobilize the “advanced” nations against Japan’s control of Korea.

    http://faroutliers.blogspot.com/

  22. hohoho your flag
    Posted April 24, 2007 at 12:38 pm | Permalink

    Robert,

    Marmot was you!
    I didn’t know that. I should have said thank you for really good explanations of that day. But you just disappeared at the Seoul Museum of History.
    Anyway it was a really good tour. Thank you again.

  23. Posted April 24, 2007 at 12:46 pm | Permalink

    Mr. Neff—The only place we were asked to stop taking photos was in front of the U.S. Ambassador’s Residence. Actually, I wouldn’t mind checking out the Ambassador’s Residence, since at least one of the old U.S. Legation buildings is still there (and controversially restored).

    As for the Russian Legation, there sure are a lot of riot cops there, but on Sunday, I walked right up to the tower to snap photos, and all the riot cops did was smile at me.

    michael—Advice well taken. I would have liked to have taken some interior shots this last time around, but unfortunately, I was helping lead a tour—a tour on a schedule—so we didn’t have much time to dwell at each structure. We did go inside Seoul Anglican Cathedral, but alas, there was a choir practice (absolutely beautiful, BTW) going on in the main hall and a mass going on in the crypt, so photos were out of the question.

    skookum—I’ll have to look into that.

  24. Posted April 24, 2007 at 12:49 pm | Permalink

    hohoho—Thanks. And of course, thanks for joining us. Sorry for kind of disappearing at the Seoul Museum of History—I can assure you it wasn’t planned :)

  25. Posted April 25, 2007 at 1:50 am | Permalink

    Is that garden at the Anglican cathedral open to the public? I have got to check it out the next time I’m in town.

    I’ve walked the big triangle around the outside of that area (Gwanghwamun-Seodaemun-Namdaemun), but I’ve never really explored the treasures inside, except for Deoksugung.

  26. railwaycharm your flag
    Posted April 25, 2007 at 7:51 am | Permalink

    Marmot, have you ever considered publishing a book? Jaundiced, may I dare say Korea enthusiasts like myself, would proudly sport a copy on the coffee table. Powerful work here!

  27. Posted April 25, 2007 at 9:57 am | Permalink

    Hey that’s my office right behind the Pai Chai Hak Dang. They actually just finished “restoring” the building. If you come in the courtyard around the front you can still used the 20′ overseas container used as the construction office. Like Mr. Neff, I too was stopped from taking pictures at the Russian Legation when I went a couple of months ago. I continued to take pictures and pretend like I couldn’t understand, however. I figured it is because it overlooks the residence compound does it not? Maybe they don’t want people scouting out the best way to attack by taking photos.

    By the way Marmot is your robert neff the same Robert Neff who wrote the Nineteenth-Century Style chapter in “Korea Witness?”

  28. Wedge your flag
    Posted April 25, 2007 at 1:55 pm | Permalink

    #27: That’s the same dood.

5 Trackbacks

  1. By The Marmot, unleashed at Lost Nomad on April 23, 2007 at 7:50 pm

    [...] you like photography, history and architecture, go and check out Robert’s latest offering.  If he keeps it up, I may actually start cutting Seoul a little [...]

  2. [...] the theme of buildings built by Dead White Guys, I bring you Part II of my Catholic church post (See Part I [...]

  3. [...] A Tour of Seoul’s Western Architecture Published April 25th, 2007 Korea , Photos Robert J. Koehler over at The Marmot’s Hole has a really amazing 3-day series of photos and history in a series he’s called ‘Buildings Built by Dead White Guys,’ or more simply, ‘The Coming of the West.’ [...]

  4. [...] Thanks to an invite kindly given to me by an acquaintance, the wife and I were lucky enough to attend the Royal Asiatic Society’s Garden Party held Saturday at the British Ambassador’s Residence, located on the grounds of the British Embassy in Seoul’s lovely Jeongdong neighborhood (which you’ll no doubt remember from this photo essay). [...]

  5. By The Marmot’s Hole » A Stroll Through Old Chemulpo on September 5, 2007 at 1:07 pm

    [...] Originally called Gakguk Park (or “All Nations Park”), Jayu Park, which covers the top of a hill overlooking the harbor, is the handiwork of Russian architect and civil engineer Afanasy Ivanovich Seredin-Sabatin, the architect behind the Chemulpo Club  (and quite a few other buildings from this era, especially in Seoul’s Jeongdong neighborhood). [...]

Post a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.